Morgan Stanley Interview Question

3 random variables have equal pairwise correlation, what are the possible value of correlation.

Interview Answers

Anonymous

Aug 14, 2012

(-1/2, 1)

12

Anonymous

May 27, 2017

Construct the correlation matrix ((1,x,x),(1,x,1),(x,1,1)) = C. For any vector v, we need dot(v, dot(C,v)) >= 0. Choose v= (1,1,1) to get x >= -1/2. To get the upper bound of 1, compute det (C) to get 2x^3 -3x^2 +1 >= 0. We know x=-1/2 is a zero, and we have 2 more. We can easily check that 1 is a zero. Thus x in [-1/2, 1].

2

Anonymous

Aug 30, 2016

from the requirement that the correlation matrix be positive semi-definite, we'd get correlation coefficient in [-1/2,1]

1

Anonymous

Aug 30, 2016

let x be the correlation (1 x x) —> the correlation matrix A = (x 1 x) should be positive semi-definite (x x 1) —> |x| == 0 —> -1/2 = why ? because intuitively, if x1 and x2 are negatively correlated, x2 and x3 are negatively correlated, then my naivety tends to tell me that x1 and x3 move in the same direction, i.e. positively correlated. but it seems like negative values for x are also possible

Anonymous

Aug 30, 2016

let x be the correlation (1 x x) —> the correlation matrix A = (x 1 x) should be positive semi-definite (x x 1) —> |x| = 0 —> -1/2 why ? because intuitively, if x1 and x2 are negatively correlated, x2 and x3 are negatively correlated, then my naivety tends to tell me that x1 and x3 move in the same direction, i.e. positively correlated. but it seems like negative values for x are also possible

Anonymous

Mar 4, 2011

0, 1.

1