401K Plan

Good 5% match no matter how much you contribute.

Profit sharing 5% no matter if employee is contributing towards 401k

Nothing particularly special, very similar to others

Put in 5% regardless of your contribution. Vested after 3 years.

They don't match 401k but have profit sharing that you don't have to contribute to

<Amount of contribution is average 4.5-5% but they don't require you to put anything in for them to make a contribution to your account.>> 3 to 5 %. And its at company's discretion based on profits for the year. If they lose money, your 3 to 5% of zero, is zero. <<Company won't match in first year of employment>> There is no matching, re-read your policy manual. Unless you mean you've made zero contribution, in which case, they also made zero contribution. That's the only matching I can see.

Company won't match in first year of employment

They have matching but full vesting is 2.5 years.

Best thing is that employer contributions begin from day one automatically, worst thing is that you are 0% vested until 3 year anniversary (but 100% at that point).