Skip to contentSkip to footer
  • Community
  • Jobs
  • Companies
  • Salaries
  • For Employers
      Notifications

      Loading...

      Elevate your career

      Discover your earning potential, land dream jobs, and share work-life insights anonymously.

      employer cover photo
      employer logo
      employer logo

      Shelter Insurance

      Engaged Employer

      About
      Reviews
      Pay & benefits
      Jobs
      Interviews
      Interviews
      Related searches: Shelter Insurance reviews | Shelter Insurance jobs | Shelter Insurance salaries | Shelter Insurance benefits
      Shelter Insurance interviewsShelter Insurance Agency Owner interviewsShelter Insurance interview
      Company Bowl sample

      Want the inside scoop on your own company?

      Check out your Company Bowl for anonymous work chats.

      Bowls

      Get actionable career advice tailored to you by joining more bowls.

      Followed companies

      Stay ahead in opportunities and insider tips by following your dream companies.

      Job searches

      Get personalized job recommendations and updates by starting your searches.

      Agency Owner Interview

      Jul 17, 2026
      Anonymous Interview Candidate
      No offer
      Negative experience
      Difficult interview

      Application

      I interviewed at Shelter Insurance

      Interview

      Long and pretentious, they have a bloated opinion of themselves and no consideration for the interviewee's time. Minimum of four interviews; the last one is 3 hours with no refreshments. Coffee or tea would have been nice. Back-to-back, with drilling scripted, check-mark questions being read with little emotion. The last of three interviews ended with some guy with a stained suit coat and the personality of the sterotypical sleezy used car salesman, who contradicted almost everything you were led to believe about the company during all of the other interviews- serious bait-and-switch interviewing with these clowns. By the end, I didn't want to work there; it literally seemed like a sleezy used car sales cult. Only 2% that make it to the final run are accepted. You might get a denial call, with the pretentious, " We know you will go on to do great things", LOL, like I didn't know that, and have actually done some great things already? And I need thier them to validate my greatness? Anyway, you've been warned. If they were honest with me in the first interview, I wouldn't have gone to the next one.

      Interview questions [1]

      Question 1

      A time when you missed a deadline, and what did you do? And can you sell our crappy Life insurance product, even though it doesn't really reduce the P&C premiums like we tell our customers it does?
      Answer question

      Other Agency Owner Interview Reviews for Shelter Insurance

      Agency Owner Interview

      Jun 18, 2023
      Anonymous employee
      Edmond, OK
      Accepted offer
      Positive experience
      Average interview

      Application

      I applied through an employee referral. The process took 3 weeks. I interviewed at Shelter Insurance (Edmond, OK) in Jun 2023

      Interview

      The interview process took about 3 weeks. I met with 3 different people. The recruiter, the sales leader (DM) and the regional manager. Each interview including a variety of behavioral questions.

      Interview questions [1]

      Question 1

      Tell me about a time when you had to negotiate with a client and what was the result.
      1 Answer

      Shelter Insurance interviews FAQs

      • Agency Owner applicants have rated the interview process at Shelter Insurance with 4 out of 5 (where 5 is the highest level of difficulty) and assessed their interview experience as 50% positive. To compare, the company-average is 63.6% positive. This is according to Glassdoor user ratings.
      • Candidates applying for Agency Owner roles take an average of 21 days to get hired, when considering 2 user submitted interviews for this role. To compare, the hiring process at Shelter Insurance overall takes an average of 29 days.
      • Common stages of the interview process at Shelter Insurance as a Agency Owner according to 2 Glassdoor interviews include:

        Background check:  20%

        Personality test:  20%

        Phone interview:  20%

        Skills test:  20%

        One on one interview:  20%

      • Here are the most commonly searched roles for interview reports -

        1. Insurance Agent(40) ;
        2. Agent(21) ;
        3. Claims Adjuster(17) ;
        4. Material Damage Adjuster(11) ;
        5. Software Engineer(11) ;
        6. Customer Service Representative(10) ;
        7. Casualty Claims Adjuster(9) ;
        8. Affiliate Agent(8) ;
        9. Salaried Agent(8) ;
        10. Agency Owner(7) ;
        11. Casualty Adjuster(7) ;
        12. Customer Service Representative (CSR)(6) ;
        13. Underwriter(6) ;
        14. Licensed Insurance Agent(5) ;
        15. Software Developer(5) .


      Glassdoor

      • About / Press
      • Awards
      • Blog
      • Research
      • Contact Us
      • Guides

      Employers

      • Free Employer Account
      • Employer Center
      • Employers Blog

      Information

      • Help
      • Guidelines
      • Terms of Use
      • Privacy & Ad Choices
      • Do Not Sell Or Share My Information
      • Cookie Consent Tool
      • Security

      Work With Us

      • Advertisers
      • Careers
      Download the App

      • Browse by:
      • Companies
      • Jobs
      • Locations
      • Communities
      • Recent Posts

      Copyright © 2008-2026. Indeed, Inc. "Glassdoor," "Worklife Pro," "Bowls," and logo are proprietary trademarks of Indeed, Inc.

      Jobs at Shelter Insurance

      79 jobs in United States
      Agent
      Bourbonnais, IL
      View job
      Insurance Agent
      Marion, IN
      View job
      Agent
      Rockford, IL
      View job
      Insurance Agent
      Appleton City, MO
      View job
      Insurance Agent
      Columbus, MS
      View job
      View all Agency Owner Jobs