employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

American National Insurance

Engaged Employer

American National Insurance reviews

2.9

36% would recommend to a friend

(278 total reviews)
avatar

Tim Walsh

42% approve of CEO

29% positive business outlook

Reviews by job title

278 reviews

Reviews about "Compensation"

Return to all reviews
3.0
Feb 5, 2026

Good Starter Job but lack of pay and benefits

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great place to work for beginner Nice people Lots of opportunities

Cons

Low salary Fully in office no exceptions Increased work hours Benefits are being taken away Concerns by employees are ignored Constant turnover

avatar
American National Insurance Response
5mo
Thank you for your review. Every piece of feedback helps us reflect on how we can continue to support our teams and improve the workplace. If you’d like to share further feedback, please email social@americannationl.com.
4.0
Dec 9, 2025

Good Company

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good Pay, fair time off, flexible teams

Cons

Bought by a bigger corporate company, so losing the mom/pop feel

avatar
American National Insurance Response
7mo
Thank you for your review. We’re committed to listening and learning from all feedback to help guide our efforts moving forward.
1.0
Aug 21, 2025

Horrible exploitative culture

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Was remote work for part of my time working there

Cons

Company promised we would never have to return to office and then rescinded their word, made everyone return to office full time Pay is way below industry standard and the raises were not even in keeping with inflation Promotional practices were completely biased to the point they wouldn't even allow qualified candidates to interview because they had already chosen who was getting the job before even posting it Supervisors will tell you to your face they will advocate for you to higher ups and then completely go back on their word You will beg for opportunities to learn more skills and be told no at every turn even when your numbers/quality of your work is above what is expected My supervisor would constantly tell my team to do things one way and then reprimand us for doing what she said after conveniently "forgetting" she was the one who told us to do it (never wrote anything down so was constantly forgetting things she changed) Same sup also told me to my face twice that it was my job to "do what the people above me don't feel like doing" which is completely insulting and untrue, associates have our OWN jobs and it's not our job to pick up others' slack when they're being negligent. It's one thing to catch someone's mistake and it's another to be expected to do things that are someone else's responsibility that they willfully don't do because everyone above you has a "the associates will do it" attitude that they get away with. I was given "meets expectations" on my yearly review and I asked what I could have done differently to get "exceeds expectations" and was told, "I don't have an answer for you, just keep doing what you're doing." I asked what I can do differently to get "exceeds" next year and was told "just repeat what you did this year." Okay... so why wasn't I given "exceeds expectations" this year if doing the exact same thing will magically get me "exceeds" next year? Just constant dangling of a carrot you will never get, and on top of that higher ups used to conduct virtual meetings from their cars WHILE DRIVING as if they didn't care at all. CEO has said some absolutely atrocious things about remote work as well. Overall associates are treated like dirt and paid even worse. This company has been hemorrhaging good employees for two years now, especially the higher ups. People who have been at this company for 10-20 years have been leaving in droves over the past two years and the culture is the reason.

avatar
American National Insurance Response
11mo
We're sorry to hear about your negative experience. Your feedback is important to us. If you have additional information to share, you can reach out via email at social@americannational.com.
Viewing 4 - 6 of 278 Reviews

Glassdoor has 975 American National Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by American National Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if American National Insurance is right for you.