employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

American Fidelity Assurance Company

Engaged Employer

Not the opportunity I was sold! - Account Manager American Fidelity Assurance Company Employee Review

2.0
Aug 5, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Base salary+commission- You're only going to make 30-35k in your first several years from a base salary, but there are good opportunities to make at least that much or more in commission. Company car with gas card- Ford Fusions, nice cars Somewhat captive sales audience- The idea is that you will have many sales opportunities when you are reservicing a group.

Cons

Confusing/misleading/often changing compensation plan-4 changes to the compensation document in less than three years. Local management doesn't even understand most recent changes. Extremely unbalanced workload- 60%+ of accounts need serviced in the 4th quarter. Management's solution, start your 4th quarter groups in September. Very unprofessional, and not in keeping with AFA's mantra of being an extension of a company's HR department. Blatant favoritism-Worst company I've ever worked for in this regard. If you are 100% of quota, but not buddies with the district manager, you will not work in the new (and therefore financially lucrative) groups. Quite the contrary in that account managers with abysmal production (but personal pals with the DM) will be put in the position to enroll these new groups. Coached to tell customers one thing while actually doing otherwise-We are told to tell everyone we meet that we are salaried account managers, but don't be fooled...this company is commission driven! Even with the lopsided workload you will be expected to be selling 4 out of 5 days a week. Again this is completely unrealistic. Additionally we are coached to tell everyone we are needs based salespeople. We tell people we are NOT policy pushers, but again once our core benefits (disability and life insurance) are saturated in a group we are expected to come up with an angle to sell our tertiary products like accident, cancer, critical illness, or my favorite riders on existing policies. In this same vein we are coached to present EVERY employee we meet with with a life insurance quote, no financial needs analysis completed (I really don't think most of the employees or especially management would even know what a needs analysis would look like). This is the very definition under insurance ethics of "pushing policies"! Unbelievable turnover- One reason I took this job was because of what was described as extremely low turnover. It was described as less than 5% turnover annually. Anyone familiar with the insurance industry will recognize this as an extremely low turnover rate. The reality is that in the last several years I have seen closer to 60-70% turnover both locally as well as nationally.

avatar
American Fidelity Assurance Company Response
11y
hank you for your feedback. We appreciate the positive comments about the base salary plus commissions, company car and sales process. Our turnover rate in the field is less than 5 percent through June of this year. We definitely want to make sure you understand the compensation structure. Please contact leah.babbit@americanfidelity.com for assistance. We encourage you to reach out to the corporate HR department, your division COO or Internal Audit with your concerns about favoritism so these can be addressed. You can call the Talent Management team at ext. 5046 and they can connect you to the right person. We hope this helps!

Explore other reviews about American Fidelity Assurance Company

5.0
Jun 2, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Literally loved working here. Lovely office and coworkers

Cons

Not a lot of opportunities to stay after internship

avatar
American Fidelity Assurance Company Response
2w
Thank you for sharing about your internship experience! We encourage you to keep an eye on current job openings on our careers site: https://americanfidelity.com/careers.
3.0
Jun 17, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Pretty good company. Well known especially in OKC. Can make money and promote quickly if you have a good state and territory. Base salary and company car provided. Travel company paid for

Cons

Not every state has the same opportunities. Frequent travel. Must pass licensing exams 3-4 in within 2 years. Job secruity contingent on passing licensing exams and meeting quota. Percentage of earnings from sales is low. Chargebacks if products not kept active for 13 months.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All