employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

American Red Cross

Is this your company?

Great mission and great people, but fundamentally broken - Disaster Program Manager American Red Cross Employee Review

2.0
Jul 22, 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- The Red Cross genuinely does have a great mission, and it's unique in the nonprofit sector in that it relies SO heavily on volunteers (this is a pro and a con). If your goal is to have a career in volunteer coordination/management, there really aren't many places that are better than ARC. You'll likely have oversight of dozens, if not hundreds of volunteers on your team. - Great mission, and you do provide tangible assistance to people as part of your job. It turns out it wasn't for me as the compassion fatigue became way too much, and we frequently deal with challenging individuals. - Many opportunities for upward and lateral moves if you embrace them. It's an organization where you can experience in almost anything if you ask. - Generally a very kind and supportive culture (but sometimes it goes too far and becomes toxic positivity). Many people who likely shouldn't be here, are still here. - Senior leadership is transparent and easy to communicate with. - A lot of autonomy and decision-making authority about on-the-ground programs. - Opportunity to work with an incredibly diverse group of people with different talents. - Surprisingly good PTO (if you're salaried) - Most offices are allowing hybrid work or fully WFH

Cons

- Insane reliance on volunteers. Red Cross volunteers are amazing, but ARC runs such a large number of programs, as well as the 24/7, immediate-assistance program (DAT) that it becomes extremely difficult to deliver the mission depending on your volunteer team, the time of year, etc. - Constantly changing expectations and huge shifts in policy with very little time to implement them. An example is DAT. For more than a year, it was fully virtual, and then they suddenly said virtual response is not allowed anymore and gave us about 2 weeks to transition back. All of this was after stating that virtual work would remain an option. - You're on call 24/7 with no differential. They'll tell you that if you get and engage volunteers, you won't be, but it's not true. Very few disaster employees across the country have the workforce necessary to not be on call at all hours, and even when there is a team, programs are so convoluted and ever-changing that you'll still get called. At dinner? On PTO? Visiting family? Sleeping because it's 3 in the morning? Doesn't matter. You'll get a call. It depends on the area you cover, but I get calls after work hours about 6 days per week, and 4 days per week I get calls between 1 AM and 4 AM. - Pay is a little ridiculous for the geographic area that Disaster employees cover. You're managing a dozen programs, hundreds of volunteers, and trying to keep track of all government and private agencies in your area for barely more than $20 an hour. - Leadership teams are very good at listening and being verbally supportive, but there are few positive changes year over year for the average employee despite the organization doing very well financially. - You deal with people on their worst days. It can easily make you jaded. Many disaster workers also deal with harassment. - Very stressful position. The problems you deal with aren't 'business problems' like a missed deadline for a slide deck (though there are a ton of those too), but they're problems that cause people to sleep on the street or not able to get their medication. - Lots of people at ARC take credit for the accomplishments of people on the ground. - Turnover is very, very frequent. A large amount of knowledge is lost with the amount of turnover every year. I've never worked in a company that so many people resign from.

Explore other reviews about American Red Cross

5.0
Apr 16, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

My experience working with the Red Cross has been great. The work is fulfilling and the people are passionate. Benefits are good - Kaiser is $6 a month!

Cons

There is work life balance, but there is an expectation to work nights and weekends.

3.0
Jul 9, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-Meaningful, mission-driven work that makes a real impact in people's lives during times of crisis. -Flexible remote work when not actively responding to disasters. -Volunteers are the heart of the organization. Many are passionate, dedicated, and genuinely enjoyable to work with. -Building strong relationships with volunteers creates an incredible support system. Many go above and beyond to help staff because they recognize the workload and truly care about the mission. -Unique opportunities to gain experience in disaster response, emergency management, crisis management, leadership, and volunteer management. -Deployment opportunities that provide exceptional professional and personal growth. -Every day is different, offering a wide variety of experiences and continuous learning. -Strong sense of teamwork and camaraderie during disaster operations.

Cons

-Inconsistent accountability for poor leadership and management behaviors. -Toxic relationship dynamics that overlook behaviors. -High burnout and chronic turnover; many employees do not remain beyond two years. -Unsustainable workload paired with unrealistic expectations. -Leadership often prioritizes metrics over employee well-being and long-term program sustainability. -Staff are frequently expected to fill operational gaps caused by declining volunteer capacity instead of receiving additional staffing support. -On-call responsibilities can feel like being available 24/7. Even when not officially on call, staff often receive calls from volunteers needing guidance, assistance finding disaster responders, or language support. -Employees who speak a second language are frequently relied upon across multiple territories for translation assistance without corresponding workload adjustments. Although translation services exist, using them is often discouraged, placing additional burden on bilingual staff. -PTO can be difficult to fully utilize because work continues to accumulate and responsibilities often remain waiting upon return. -Compensation does not reflect the workload, level of responsibility, or work-life sacrifices expected. Salaried employees often work well beyond 40 hours without additional compensation. - Recognition and incentives appear to be uneven across departments, while frontline disaster relief staff often carry significant operational demands with limited comparable rewards. -Diversity is more visible in entry-level and lower management roles than in senior leadership.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All