Not the best place to work - Member Service Guide Devoted Health Employee Review

1.0
Aug 1, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

the benefits and thorough training

Cons

-Amy the supervisor was always sarcastic and left early on many occasions -Amy the supervisor was not professional; always posting her newest tattoo in the slack group chat -heavy micromanaging -choose to give pto to who they want -back to back calls with no breaks/stressful -no room for advancement -not open to feedback/critique -threatened to fire me for being on approved leave -only care about the money not the employees -mistakes can't happen; you'll be seen as incompetent -if your calls are rated below 85%, they'll put you on a success plan for 1 month

avatar
Devoted Health Response
1y
Hello, Thank you for taking the time to share your perspective and experience with us as a Member Service Guide. We're glad you've appreciated our benefits and training programs, yet we're sorry to learn about your negative experiences. Regarding our PTO policy, we strive for a balanced approach to ensure low wait times, compliant speed-to-answer, and manageable workloads for our team. While we aim to approve time-off equitably, busy periods might pose challenges when PTO can be more difficult to approve. These times are communicated in advance for better planning. It’s unfortunate to learn that you did not have a positive experience with this process. Member Service Guide as a department is proud to be a collaborative and welcoming environment. With various slack channels, our goal is to provide a virtual space so that employees who wish to connect on their personal lives can do so. We regret that your experience didn't meet this expectation. Our department's objectives align closely with our mission, which calls for maintaining high standards due to federal regulations. We recognize this can be demanding and offer stress reduction programs, including live and recorded classes, Lyra Benefit, and the Calm App. Feedback shows 97% of participants found these helpful. We also aim to provide growth opportunities through our tiering system, supporting both professional and financial advancement. Ensuring both our members and team feel valued is our core mission. We know that each experience is different and we welcome the opportunity to hear more from you about your perspective so we can learn. If you’d like to continue the conversation, please reach out to Michelle Mulcahy at mmulcahy@devoted.com. Thank you again, People Team at Devoted Health

Explore other reviews about Devoted Health

5.0
Jun 10, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-Welcoming and kind employee culture -Support and strong project feedback -Clear communication -Employees believe and support the mission of the company -Enthusiastic, talented, and passionate leaders

Cons

- There are two office spaces for hybrid work- they are great facilities but there are only two

3.0
Mar 4, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The mission to serve Medicare members well was clear, and the early culture reflected that. Teams were empowered, different leadership styles were welcomed, and people were trusted to solve problems in practical ways. There are still many talented and mission-driven people at the company who care deeply about the work and about members.

Cons

As the company grew rapidly, the culture began to change. Metrics have always been a focus, which is understandable in a performance-driven environment, but the emphasis increasingly shifted toward tracking activity and “effort” rather than measuring meaningful outcomes. Smaller assignments that once would have been handled with flexibility began to receive disproportionate attention, creating an environment that often felt more micromanaged than empowered. At the same time, accountability did not always appear to be applied consistently across leadership levels, which can be frustrating for teams that are being held to strict standards themselves. Frequent performance framework changes and constant iterations also created confusion and fatigue on the ground. In several cases, supervisor turnover concentrated under the same leadership should have been treated as a signal worth examining. Overall morale in parts of the organization has noticeably declined compared to earlier years.

5
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All