Merry Go Round of Leadership - Anonymous employee Flagstar Bank Employee Review

2.0
Jul 10, 2015
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Flagstar was (emphasis on was) a great place to be for many years. For many years it still operated as the tight knit, family run, community bank that made it successful. When the banking crisis hit the revolving door of leadership began that continues to today.

Cons

Multiple CEOs, COO, CFOs, CLOs, CIOs, Banking Leadership, Lending Leadership, Servicing Leadership has lead to a fragmented direction.

Explore other reviews about Flagstar Bank

5.0
Feb 27, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Very knowledgeable and helpful people who are experts in enterprise systems

Cons

N/A during my time with the company

2.0
Mar 10, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Benefits are decent. Average PTO

Cons

My experience with this company has been disappointing. Branch goals are unrealistic with no marketing or brand awareness to support the high goals and teams feel defeated. Senior leadership often communicates in a demeaning way, which has contributed to high turnover and declining morale. Despite emphasizing the importance of ‘hiring right,’ the President of Consumer Banking has cycled through three heads of Consumer Banking in just three years. The annual review process is long and drawn out (5 month process) and feels inconsistent and more like a popularity contest than a true evaluation of performance. Although the scale ranges from 1–5, employees are told that most ratings will fall in the 2–3 range, with 4s being rare and 5s essentially unattainable. The calibration process appears to focus more on filling predetermined rating quotas than assessing actual contributions. Employees are required to write their own reviews, which are then rewritten by leadership before being sent to HR for calibration. The final ratings often seem influenced more by internal politics than by merit. Annual increases are very minimal or zero. Overall, the environment lacks transparency, fairness, and genuine support for employee growth.

5
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All