Nothing is ever enough, you can be the best and it wont save your job - Customer Service GEICO Employee Review

3.0
Apr 16, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

pay, profit sharing, rewards and really thats it

Cons

management, favoritism, goals always changing, PIP evaluations due to ever changing goals, constant micro management, cant even go to the bathroom without being called out for not taking your fair share of calls. The list goes on. I was the top on my floor and I didnt transfer 2 calls to renters (FYI im not a sales agent Im a service agent!) and was accused of purposely avoiding MOAT transfers. First of all, why would I do that? I dont need to do that. Second of all, maybe have a supervisor that helps you after youve continuously asked them for help and that you are overwhelmed with the number of MOAT transfers you receive. I was taking 1100 calls a month. 1100! The number of renters and home policies i was required to upsale to that department was at least 950 calls a month. 950! When i contacted my supervisor and advised I was overwhelmed, nothing was done. Still i worked hard for this company and did everything they asked me to. The calls are too much, the metrics overwhelming. I mean 1100 calls in a month! They pay well sure but there just isnt enough support. If youre a favorite on the team, you might receive that extra help but if youre not, youll be looking for a job soon. This was not the best experience for me and maybe its not that way for everyone. The job drains you and burns you out within the year and they think by paying you well, it pays for all the stress on your heart and lost time with your family. The supervisors are not helpful. THey stand around and talk while you handle back to back calls and are screamed at all while trying desperately to meet these crazy metrics. At the end of the day, it was just too much. YOu cant take that many calls in a busy call center environment and not begin to feel stifled and over it.

Explore other reviews about GEICO

5.0
Jun 8, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

GEICO is one of the largest employers in my smaller town, so I've heard all the good, the bad, and the ugly. What a pleasant surprise it's been working here! There is so much intentional change to create a great employee experience and get the right team leaders in place. Highly recommend not putting too much weight into older negative comments if you're thinking about applying. I've been very happy with my salary, the benefits/time off, culture, and leadership (both locally and senior leaders). I feel like there's a lot of room to continue to grow my career here and I see the same opportunities for others.

Cons

Really nothing major that I can think of!

2.0
Jul 13, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Decent pay and remote work.

Cons

Poor management at all levels, and high turnover in the IT department. Profit sharing was initially offered when I started in 2013 but disappeared after covid. Management laid off most of the IT staff that had the technical and insurance knowledge in favor of bringing in new staff to transition GEICO into a tech company. Not sure what the status of the IT department is in 2026.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All