I have never left a job so quickly! - Care Manager Healthfirst Employee Review

2.0
Dec 9, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Decent pay, benefits and PTO. Remote work and thorough training.

Cons

They lure you in with the promise of a low caseload (135) but the truth is that the workload is very intense. As a new care manager they overwhelm you with brand new members who are very lengthy to complete. Their care plan and post discharge documentation requirements are like a college essay and on top of that you’re audited every month and deducted points on what you miss. Then there’s the IVR (phone) system! You’re unable to walk away without changing your status even if its a quick trip to the bathroom. We were required to answer our teammates incoming calls and take a message. We’re also required to be available for a certain timeframe of the day to answer phones which disturbs work flow. If you miss a call it counts towards your “abandonment rate” which is very anxiety inducing. My manager was the micromanagement queen, she would call multiple times a day on teams and did not believe in just answering an email, she had to call me and overly explain things like Im a child. I truly felt like I was back in school. She would say things like “we cannot stay stagnant” even though I was meeting my metrics. Only 4 people on the team could be out at a time which is not ideal specially during the holidays. Like I said in my title i have never left a job quickly enough. My anxiety was through the roof trying to meet their demans and expectations. I have worked for a couple of other health plans throughout my career and have never experienced anything like this! Stay away if you’re looking for flexibility!

avatar
Healthfirst Response
1y
We are sorry to hear that you’ve had a negative experience. Healthfirst is a mission and purpose driven organization. Our members are our North Star, and our mission is guided by their needs. We encourage each and every employee to live these principles as well, and we hope it’s reflected in day-to-day activities. We hope you felt comfortable voicing your concerns while you were a Healthfirst team member. We wish you all the best in your career.

Explore other reviews about Healthfirst

5.0
May 15, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Friendly, remote, flexible, good pay w experience

Cons

Long weeks of training Monday - Friday for 8 weeks

1.0
May 8, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Generous Salary, Paid Time Office , and 401K match.

Cons

Very toxic leadership and favoritism in management Different rules for favorite employees and managers Return-to-office policy not enforced equally Employees blamed while ineffective managers were protected

4
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All