A mixed bag for freelancers: 2/5 bad, 3/5 good - Copy Editor Leaf Group Employee Review

2.0
Jun 15, 2011
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Helps laid off media professionals (editors & writers) keep our foot in the door of our field and keep using/maintaining our skills ("use it or lose it" definitely applies in copy editing). - Can work from home, library, coffeeshop, anywhere my laptop can get the internet - Can work as many or as few hours each day/week as I like - I like learning new things based on the variety of article topics I copy edit - Company has expanded over the years to provide copy for more websites and bigger-name websites, which makes me proud to say I edit for Demand - Company pays promptly 2x per week, and via PayPal, which makes it very simple. There have never been any errors in what I'm paid (I always get what I was supposed to get) - Occasionally on significant holiday weekends (Thanksgiving, Memorial Day, etc.) the company runs a sweepstakes where each article a writer submits, or each article a CE edits, earns entries into the sweeps, which is usually airline tickets or a cash amount. That's definitely a motivator and it also is a morale booster. (I haven't won yet but I will always keep trying!)

Cons

- The pay rate for both editors and writers is too low for what we're expected to do - Sometimes I get articles in my queue whose topics are not ones that I indicated on my preferences that I want to edit. I don't know why they show up - Whatever test or criteria the company uses to select writers is seriously flawed. I'm shocked at how often I encounter articles with embarrassing errors in very *basic* grammar, syntax, punctuation and AP Style. Do these writers not care, does Demand not care, or both? - We edit directly via a web interface/template on the Demand website & the site often has technical difficulties, especially on weekends when a lot of editors & writers want to work - Sending help requests to the help desk is frustrating because either they never respond, or they take a very long time to respond - Asking questions or airing concerns in the community forums on the website is not always helpful because often, the higher-ups who *should* answer the questions, don't answer, which leaves many of us feeling dissed and/or floundering - HIgher-ups rarely ever ask for input from editors & writers when making significant changes to the site, to the writing/editing process, to the style sheets, etc. Suddenly we are notified of some big change, and even if a bunch of us then comment (in the forums) that we don't like it for this or that reason, we are often ignored and nothing is addressed

Explore other reviews about Leaf Group

5.0
Feb 7, 2024
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great Management Transparency into company performance Cute brands Smart people

Cons

Can be chaotic at times due to a lot of responsibility across multiple brands

4.0
Jan 29, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Exciting work environment, exposure to many different industries, great office space, pay was above average

Cons

commute into Santa Monica was brutal

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All