Micro-management at its best - Claims MEMIC Employee Review

1.0
Mar 22, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

They hire great claims people--but then take them down a few notches...

Cons

I worked in a MEMIC office in New England (not the Home Office in Portland) for almost 10 years. For the first few years, it was by far the best company I ever worked for. After that, things changed, and management became very full of itself. It is hugely top-heavy and the promotions to managers, supervisors, directors and vice presidents is ridiculous. I think 400 people work for the company and more than a quarter of these people are management. Although the claims workload looks like it would be minimal, the additional stress of the constant audits from the compliance department make it a negative place to work on a daily basis. It's fairly common place to see people crying at their desks. Management dosen't care that people are frustrated and leave the company, even after being there for years. They tend to joke about it, assuming that they can get new people to come in... athough it takes months to find people. Sometimes they don't even bother filling the position and just give extra workloads to the adjusters that are left, without any consideration to the effect on customer service. In fact, the VP of claims was once overheard saying "sometimes turnover is a great thing!" He's getting his wish, which is too bad, because of the people that have left, had they felt appreciated, they probably would have stayed. The insurance industry is a small one, it's not good to have a bad reputation with micro-management of employees. If you are in underwriting or loss control, you are treated like gods. Claims people are the bottom of the barrel at MEMIC, and considered dispensable. It's obvious in their hiring procedures. They want current adjusters to recommend new people to come to the company...An adjuster referral is worth $100. Loss control and underwriters are worth up to $3,500. It's just insulting.

avatar
MEMIC Response
7y
First, a sincere thanks for your feedback. You are right that many things have changed at MEMIC during our significant growth over the past several years. In fact, we doubled the number of employees and have now opened offices from Maine to Florida. To achieve that growth we created a structure we feel confident will respond to continued growth and one that replicates the service standards that have gained us recognition with agents, policyholders, and the insurance industry. The Claim department is where we deliver on the promise of insurance and sincere care for injured workers. As you may also know, we are investing heavily in a new claim management system to ease workloads, speed decision making and continue our record for timely compliance. That’s not to say we’ve done everything perfectly. Growth and change are the two most challenging aspects for all organizations. That said, we are investing in management training and a lot more cross department communication. That’s just some of what our all-employee survey indicated and we’re making steady progress. Finally, thank you for your feedback on the referral program. We typically start our positions at the first tier, and then escalate based on the difficulty to fill the position.

Explore other reviews about MEMIC

5.0
May 6, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good benefits, management, hybrid schedules

Cons

Work life balance, no other cons

avatar
MEMIC Response
1mo
Thank you for sharing your experience. We’re glad to hear you enjoyed working at MEMIC and appreciated the benefits, management, and collaborative company culture. We recognize that work/life balance can look different across roles and individuals, and we continue to focus on supporting flexibility and balance in ways that meet the needs of our team. We encourage open communication with managers to help problem solve these scenarios. We appreciate your feedback and your contributions during your time with us.
5.0
Dec 9, 2025
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great benefits Sr. Leadership continuously adapting to keep workforce engaged - including management training, gallup engagement action planning, adjusting benefits package/bonus structure. All while keeping profitable growth at the forefront to keep the company secure as a stable employer.

Cons

Lots of ongoing change, so being nimble is important. Not necessarily a con, but can be if navigating change is hard for you. Upward mobility opportunities are limited, as it's not the largest employer relative to the industry. Also not necessarily a con, unless that's essential for you.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All