Money Can't Buy Happiness - Supervisor McMaster-Carr Employee Review

1.0
Oct 20, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great pay, bonuses, pension plan, and health benefits. You can meet some truly wonderful people across the individual contributor track and management.

Cons

Now for the bad. I joined McM halfway through my MBA program. Because McM has so many employees at top-tier part-time MBA programs, I met a handful of them. I got mixed reviews but chose to ignore the bad reviews and leave a job where I was happy for more money. If I can summarize my thoughts after reading many of the reviews: please do yourself a favor a don't believe the ones that paint a nice picture. McM has a bizarre 'apartheid' between those in the management track (my role) and the individual contributors. Leadership says they are trying to change the culture, but it's not even remotely true. The company runs on the work individual contributors do, but they do not get any appreciation - they are just supposed to be cogs in the machine. In order to advance in your career in management, you have to be a yes man. No opinions that deviate from the infallible mouths of senior leadership are to be tolerated. If you make the mistake of contradicting the opinions of senior leadership once, it is almost impossible to get back in their good graces. Other reviews have alluded to this before, but there are weekly/periodic meetings where management in a department meets with senior leadership to review the individual contributors' work. These meetings are intended to get a pulse check on the operation and gauge the team's performance, but they are a colossal waste of time and are only an opportunity for senior leadership to share their wisdom (or lack thereof). I've seen a few reviews from folks who have drunk the kool-aid saying that only those in management that are low-performers have bad experiences at McM. In a sense, that may be true because the evaluation of your performance depends on who your manager is and the relationship you have with them. But, more accurately, it is because there is no transparency in performance standards, and no regular feedback on performance (at least in my experience). At the end of the day, we're not saving lives here. We're selling nuts and bolts. It's not rocket science, and we don't have to pretend we are an elite workforce based solely on credentials from 'elite institutions'. For those who are considering working in management at McM, reflect on these bad reviews. There are only two realistic paths at McM: - get your MBA and get out (if you make it that far) - dedicate your career to the company, play the internal politics game, and hope you have a nice nest egg at the end

Explore other reviews about McMaster-Carr

5.0
Jun 7, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Salary, benefits, coworkers, work/life balance

Cons

micromanagement at every level and job is boring at times

2.0
Mar 4, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good salary, guaranteed bonus, opportunities for overtime

Cons

Management changes constantly, managers are either fresh out of college or have never done your role or both, so I felt like I was managing myself. The metric standards are so high you have to essentially be perfect month after month. The standards are completely unrealistic, robotic, and leave little room for a bad day. There is PTO but you are only allowed to take it if there are “available hours” for that day - everything is about capacity and squeezing out as much work from as many people as possible. Taking time off affects your metrics for the month, which I did not know until after I took my first week-long vacation - they are always looking at your performance in terms of the past year, so I had to try to overwork and correct the bad month I had, when in my opinion your PTO should be completely YOUR time and have no adverse effect. Mentally and physically strenuous, whether you are on the warehouse side or office side - go to the bathroom too many times in a day and it will become an issue - they expect you to be glued to your desk/post. Like I said, no room to be human.

7
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All