If you want overtime, experience, and little work/life balance, they may be for you. - Department Manager Menards Employee Review

3.0
Feb 7, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I worked for Menards for over 13 years. The Pros: Any employee that works over 1000 hours, part time or full time, gets a profit sharing bonus the following Feb. If you quit before the end of the year, you lose it. If you're in management, you are paid hourly, plus overtime, plus weekly payroll bonuses, plus yearly bonuses based on the department's profit. For an assistant manager, this equals out to be around $30-40k depending on how long you've been there. A department manager makes $40-55k, depending on how long you've been there.

Cons

They are a VERY performance-based private company. If you are not on time, driven, and successful in management, you will be replaced or demoted. If you quit before Dec. 31st, you lose all profit sharing and department manager bonuses. This company expects you to spend more time here than with family and as a manager, you are required to work at least 2 nights per week and every other weekend. Vacations are scheduled in November for the following year, and it is first come, first serve. If another manager that has more experience than you requests Christmas week off, he/she gets it. Also, if you want to get into store management, you MUST move to another store and they give you no options. It is their decision, and if you take it, great. If not, you'll be stuck exactly where you are. Corporate operations has built a network of fear around all of their employees that anyone can and will be fired. John Menard has a strong track record of firing people close to him that may be a threat to his position..........

Explore other reviews about Menards

5.0
May 31, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Worked with lots of people

Cons

Lots of manual labor for hardware

2.0
Jun 22, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

A few of the people are nice to work with.

Cons

A store manager who talks down to employees like they're children (and apparently gets promoted for it). A store manager who acts like employees are idiots for calling him to ask questions. Raises are pathetic. Understaffed because the store manager won't allow enough labor hours to do the job, particularly on Sundays when there's a lot of freight.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All