employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

New York Public Library

Is this your company?

Great Organization with an inspiring mission, terrible digital leadership - Software Engineering Manager New York Public Library Employee Review

1.0
Jan 8, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Good work/life balance - Good retirement and decent benefits package - Inspiring mission, the organization as a whole truly cares about the communities they serve

Cons

This organization, while I was there, was struggling to find their way in a digital world. Their chief digital officer had begun to assemble a team to lead their digital technology efforts which involved eReading and digital experiences like their website, digital research, etc. These teams were, as I came to learn, dealing with a lot of legacy systems and technical debt, and the leadership I reported into at the time was extremely toxic, petty, and overall, simply cruel. It became clear to me after several months that the person in charge of hiring software engineering talent before I joined (my supervisor) wasn't interested in dealing with their software engineers anymore. After a few months, I'd find myself in meetings with senior director level employees, including this person, where they would routinely call out other, lower level employees by name to gossip about them, and there was almost no focus on any kind of strategic objective for the department other than vague "stability" concerns about their existing software. There were recurring "sprint review" meetings set up, but they were actually just status update meetings for the directors in disguise. I was also told several times that more than one employee that I ended up managing likely needed to go on a performance improvement plan, but I saw no such evidence of this once I started working with these people individually - more likely, they were simply never spoken to like they were human beings or given a chance to excel in their roles. The direction I did receive, when I got any at all, was to put together technical "roadmaps" for the digital team, but without any OKRs or cadence based planning at the organizational level this became an exercise in futility where what no matter what I produced, it was nitpicked to the point of being useless. When I tried to assert any kind of view that I thought could help out the digital organization such as a heavier emphasis on agile and lean planning principles, I was told to basically shut up and only focus on "technical" things. I sincerely wish the NYPL the best and I hope things have changed since I left. I would not recommend working there if you're in a technical role.

Explore other reviews about New York Public Library

5.0
Mar 18, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The Library is dynamic and interesting. There are many intelligent, dedicated people working there. I learned a lot and got to work on some cool stuff.

Cons

it could benefit from more project management.

3.0
May 26, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Unparalleled work-life balance, especially for tech workers. - A very relaxed and friendly environment with no micromanagement. - Generous leave policies. - Most projects have very slow deadlines, so there’s no significant work pressure. - A laissez-faire work culture. - If you’re contemplating retirement, pursuing a master’s degree, or starting a side hustle, this is an excellent place to work.

Cons

- Compensation is significantly below market rate. - Toxic directors and senior leaders favor certain employees and encourage sycophancy. Sycophants are rewarded with benefits such as flexible work schedules and the ability to work remotely. - Promotion is contingent upon being a sycophant. - Directors and senior leaders often avoid the office altogether or have erratic schedules, such as arriving at 7 pm and leaving whenever they please, while simultaneously enforcing strict rules. - If you’re an ambitious individual seeking career growth, this is not the ideal place to be.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All