Ups and Downs - Payroll Specialist Paycor Employee Review

4.0
Jul 22, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-Generous PTO allotment right from hire date which refreshes every year. Typically start you off with 20 days or more of PTO right from day 1. -They definitely ease you into your role, and will ultimately take 6-8 months to feel like your actually working full time. This is great if your hesitant about a role that your not too familiar with and gives you time to really soak in your role. -Most supervisors are generally laidback and allow you to control your, "destiny". They are not micro-managers by nature. If you put effort into your work then you generally won't hear much from your supervisor aside from your one on one session. -Retention has improved, and teams have grown in size over the months and years, translating to feeling less overwhelmed with work because you feel that you need to tackle the work of multiple people. -Access to a thrive account which is employer provided, which gives you a stipend for technology, health and wellness, etc. -The overall work culture is definitely more relaxed as a whole versus some other major public companies.

Cons

-Unfair compensation. Pay increases have been minimal at best. Over 5 and half years my pay has only increase by 2 dollars per hour. There are definitely other payroll companies that are more aggressive and competitive with wages. -Micromanagement, while better than most companies, has become much more prevalent during the time paycor has become public. Prior to their IPO they were the least micro managing company I had ever worked for, since then, they have put in a slew of new measurement systems that grade you for things you feel are irrelevant to your actual role. -Your manager might have no experience with your actual role, and is there to solely manage activity and your measurement goals that they set out for the department and you, This makes it difficult, not only due to lack of relatability to your role, but also due to lack of leadership/knowledge with questions and concerns that might arise to your actual role. -Over-time has been scaled back quite a bit. Before it was highly acceptable and expected quite often, now it's highly frowned upon unless there is a serious reason why you are working over. -Cross department communication is severely lacking on good days, and non existent on bad days. It often feels like the right hand doesn't know what the left hand is ultimately doing at times, which can make things difficult when clients come out of implementation needing multiple fixes and repairs to there account and expect you to spear head all of the fixes -You definitely feel like you are tackling a lot of different projects at times just due to the nature of the job, and while the best days feel like a walk on the beach, the worst days can definitely make you want to pull your hair out and walk away. -Year end during early December is a black out period that last thru the beginning of December until beginning of February. Meaning no pto can be used, and any time off taken is extremely frowned upon. These few months are easily the hardest most challenging times at paycor, and what will ultimately make or break you. Volume is extremely high during these times and there is a lot of pressure that will be applied to you during this period by senior management. If you are accepting of no holiday vacations during your tenure with Paycor, and are able to push thru the busyness of year end, then everything afterwards feels like the, "calm after the storm".

Explore other reviews about Paycor

5.0
May 27, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great management and work from home.

Cons

Low pay…everything else was great

1.0
Jun 11, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Paycheck hits on time every two weeks.

Cons

I wanted to like working at Paycor. The product has potential and the pitch during the interview process sounded promising. But the reality of day-to-day life here is a far cry from what's advertised. Micromanagement is rampant. Leadership tracks every minute of your day — from login times to bathroom breaks — yet somehow trusts no one to make even the smallest decision independently. You're treated like a number, not a professional. There's zero autonomy, and any attempt to take initiative is quickly shut down. The leadership team is deeply out of touch. Many managers got their roles through tenure, not merit, and it shows. They struggle to answer basic questions about the industry, lean on buzzwords in meetings, and consistently make decisions that anyone with relevant experience would know to avoid. When things go wrong, blame rolls downhill fast. The culture is toxic and cliquey. If you're not in the right social circle, advancement is nearly impossible. Favoritism is blatant, feedback is rarely constructive, and the "open door policy" is a joke — speak up and you'll find yourself quietly pushed out. The work environment doesn't help either. High turnover means institutional knowledge constantly walks out the door. Morale is low, burnout is high, and HR seems more interested in protecting the company than the employees.

1
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All