Toxic - Anonymous employee Robert Half Employee Review

1.0
Jul 22, 2014
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The actual job responsibilities are extremely easy. The management touts the position as a sales job, but it’s really order-taking. If you have any sort of B2B sales experience, the responsibilities & expectations are a piece of cake. Another pro, is that because it’s not remotely a real sales job, you walk out the door at 5:30pm on the dot, and never have to think about work in your off-hours, as they do not require or encourage you to access email remotely. Additionally, it takes very little mental effort to perform at this job, as you are not required to make any decisions regarding how to use the time in your work day. Robert Half will tell you when you pick up the phone, when to be at your desk, when to go the bathroom and when to go home for the day. Additionally, you will not have a direct phone number, so you will never have to check your voice mail. This also saves you from actually developing relationships with your clients, which is done to protect Robert Half when you eventually move on from the company. Robert Half will not send you to New Hire training until you have worked for at least 90 days, as the likelihood of you leaving the company in less than 90 days is extremely high. Unlike your previous sales job, you do not have to start your employment by getting on a plane to attend corporate sales training with your fellow colleagues & peers! Instead you will spend week 1 reading the online training manuals at your desk, and by week 2, you will jump right in & pick up the phones. The biggest pro of working at Robert Half Legal, is that after about 6 months, you will be heavily recruited by every staffing firm across all industries. Other staffing firms understand the environment at Robert Half produces employees who will work hard and see high levels of success in a more nurturing environment. If you can defy the odds, and remain employed here beyond 18+ months, you will be one of the longest-tenured employees in a department of 25+ people, and there is good money to be made.

Cons

The environment on the Legal team in Chicago is downright toxic. Twenty percent of the department turns over completely every 6 months. It’s an almost exclusively female environment, heavily populated with ex-attorneys who act superior to their peers, though all members of the team hold the Account Executive or Recruiter title, and not everyone needed a JD to get there. It’s extremely catty, condescending and demotivating. If your management is not discussing your clothes or shoes behind your back, they are criticizing your wardrobe and hair to your face. It’s incredibly unprofessional, offering very little constructive feedback that would advance your career. Be prepared to have more meetings about your nail polish or the color of your jacket, than your sales numbers or a plan to improve them. Management will actively & openly fight over commissions from the reps that report to them. It’s a very much “do as I say, not as I do” environment. You are constantly questioned on your whereabouts, as it is not a true inside/outside sales role. Your clients will have at least 2-4 contacts in the legal department alone, so be prepared to battle your teammates for orders. If you list an emergency contact on your private HR records, know that if you are late to work, they will contact them, questioning your whereabouts. There is a high level of incompetence among the management team locally in Chicago, as none of them have ever held a supervisory role outside of Robert Half. The key to success is not unlike junior high: get into the inner circle and you will see success, as it is your direct manager, not you, who determines your level of success.

Explore other reviews about Robert Half

5.0
May 20, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Leadership, Compensation, Team Work, Flexible Schedule, Work Life Balance

Cons

Pay is based on a draw, so you have to cover your monthly base pay to receive the bonus

avatar
Robert Half Response
2mo
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re glad to hear you’ve had a positive experience with leadership, teamwork, flexibility, and work-life balance. We also appreciate your perspective regarding compensation structure, and will share these comments with our leadership team as we review improvements.
2.0
Jul 23, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Easy role, no different than any other agency As long as you do the job, they don't look to fire anyone until after year 1/2

Cons

Commission isn't great In-office culture is for the sake of micro-management and not collaboration. Very much our way or the highway; you will genuinely get in trouble for asking questions about their process. Also, they primarily operate under the legacy of Robert Half's name rather than on actual specialization and knowledge in the market. It's an old-school boys' club; they don't respect you until you've survived 2 years, and even then, multiple women mentioned that certain male managers weren't easy to work with and didn't value their experience. Even HR isn't supportive, especially if the problem is someone high enough on the food chain. Salary transparency is actually frowned upon internally. There isn't a culture of collaboration; the way the commission structure operates, everyone works against each other to make the deal. And if perm and contract are working on the same role, they actively work against each other, which isn't comfortable for anyone. They're so eager for work that they operate as 'yes men' and not as actual consultants on the market, and will not stand up for their candidates if they can close a deal. They use AI to train recruiters on how to match keywords on resumes to candidate profiles, not to actually understand who they're looking for or how to evaluate them properly.

avatar
Robert Half Response
4d
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We strive to foster a collaborative and supportive workplace where employees can grow and succeed. We appreciate your perspective and will take your comments into consideration as we continue to evaluate and improve the employee experience.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All