employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

SurePayroll

Part of Paychex

Is this your company?

Take the Good with the Bad - Anonymous employee SurePayroll Employee Review

3.0
Jan 3, 2022
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

SurePayroll actually has a great culture for their employees, depending on what department you work in. I will say that at SurePayroll, lower & middle management is great and loves identifying new talent. I was willing to learn and was invested in, so have easily moved up to different roles that I wasn't initially qualified for. If you find the right manager, they might take the time to develop their employees. However, with other managers I have seen that if you sparkle/stand out they make fast moves to stifle you for fear that you may outshine them. I've worked in several different Departments, and can verify that there are a lot of internal benefits. Being a Paychex employee is great, PTO, health insurance, Retirement match, paid/free lunches and their flexibility regarding your schedule is great. Also, a lot of Departments are still able to work from home, which is a huge benefit. However, not all Departments are treated the same. Sales & Service are basically the workhorses of the company. All the other Departments try to support them as much as possible, but Sales/Service is always understaffed. Leadership seems to enjoy keeping them as light staffed as possible, for some unknown reason (probably offering low pay). I will say that Sales does have the opportunity to make a lot of money, if you hit your quotas right and get the compounder. If you are really talented, you may qualify for Paychex's Sales Conference, which is a great experience. However, the last two years their conference has been virtual, which is a lot less fun than traveling to Hawai'i and enjoying the beach.

Cons

Our Leadership team is stuck in 2012, like our software. There is so much tech debt that it makes it hard to develop new technologies or ideas cause you've gotta wait in a crazy technical queue for 2+ years so they can build something that someone thought up in 2018. Leadership has been in place for so long that there are hardly any new ideas. They keep switching upper management around instead of bringing in new talent and new mindsets. If managers don't fall in line, they won't succeed and are quickly kicked out the door. Sales & Service have the worst PTO limitations, they're not able to take time off from December - March. Seems pretty silly when the rest of the Departments are basically Out of Office for the second half of December.

Explore other reviews about SurePayroll

5.0
Jan 21, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great benefits, company and people

Cons

Low base pay, a lot of changes

1.0
Apr 22, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good pay, decent benefits, unlimited time off.

Cons

From the start, it was uncomfortably obvious that at least half of the people in marketing had problems with one another. You could actively feel the tension in every interaction: during video calls, in email threads, even in Slack chats, etc. At first, I blamed structural issues. The various marketing teams were set up in a confusing way, and it wasn’t clear who owned what or who made final decisions. So I understood why everyone felt like their toes were being stepped on. However, I really think it goes beyond that. There’s a fundamental lack of respect, and it’s led to an extremely negative and passive aggressive environment. The pay is slightly above market value, which is what led me to accept the job in the first place (despite one of my pre-employment interviews with the team being so tense and uncomfortable that the hiring manager actually had to apologize). However, I really wish I had trusted my gut. My experience at SurePayroll was by far my least favorite of my entire career.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All