A good "stepping stone" company, yet not a place to stay long-term - Anonymous employee Uncommon Goods Employee Review

3.0
Mar 18, 2015
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

>The people are great. Best part of the company. >Casual dress code. >The company tries its best to "give back." Always proud to say this. >I genuinely think the CEO is a great guy, just a little lost with the company's direction and has a disconnect with others. >Exciting to be surrounded around lots of interesting items. >Did I mention that the people are awesome?

Cons

>Location. The walk from the subway to the offices is HORRIBLE. Worst part of my day. Also, have fun finding a decent place to eat for lunch. >They pretend they care about work-life balance - but in the end, they honestly don't. >The company has an identity crisis. They want to appeal to everyone. Marketing 101: choose your audience! >They don't pay their full time employees the amount a NYC professional should be paid. Several people leave the company and find a job in that same field in NYC for 10-20k more. They lowball you as much as possible. They do a lot of talk about bringing up the minimum wage for hourly workers (which is great) but when it comes to their full time employees - it's like pulling teeth to just get a simple increase in pay. Loyalty of staying with the company for years means nothing to them - they would rather let you go, hire someone else who accepts the low ball salary - before giving you the salary you deserve. (Also heard this from multiple people from different departments.) I'm sure they give all their higher up managers a decent pay because if they leave everything would go crazy. But everyone else...peanuts. >They don't take risks at all. There's a lot of "we should do this and that" but "this and that" never, ever happens. It's all talk. >The website is very old fashioned compared to other e-commerce sites. The creative team does a great job with images and the direction they receive, but in the end, the overall template is very bland. >They want to market towards a younger audience but won't make any major changes to the type of products they curate and the marketing strategies aren't very dynamic. >Individual face-to-face time with employees are great but for some reason during the day when everyone is sitting together at their desks the mood is very awkward and gloomy. >A huge part of their profit is still dependent on catalogs. A bit bizarre and scary. >I would recommend this place to a friend only if they didn't have any other great prospects. But with that recommendation, I would have about 20 warnings along with it.

Explore other reviews about Uncommon Goods

5.0
Oct 29, 2025
Anonymous freelancer
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The management is great and very supportive, pay is good and everyone works great as a team.

Cons

Only a temporary position as the bulk of their business is the last quarter of the year.

avatar
Uncommon Goods Response
8mo
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with Uncommon Goods! We’re delighted to hear that you enjoyed your time with us and found our management team and work environment to be supportive and collaborative. You’re right - our busiest season is during the holidays, and we bring on many talented freelancers and seasonal team members to help us deliver great experiences for our customers during that time. We truly value the energy and contribution of everyone who joins us for the season and hope that the experience is rewarding and memorable. We appreciate your feedback and wish you the very best in your next opportunity!
4.0
May 13, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Pays Good Supervisors are super nice

Cons

Bathroom stinks or are in horrible condition Sometime hire aggrieve and crazy ppl

avatar
Uncommon Goods Response
1mo
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We're glad to hear that you had a positive experience with your supervisors and found our compensation competitive. We also appreciate your raising concerns about the condition of our restrooms. Providing a clean, safe, and comfortable workplace is important to us, and feedback like this helps us identify areas for improvement. As for your comments regarding coworkers, we recognize that every workplace brings together people with different personalities, backgrounds, and working styles. We strive to foster a respectful, inclusive environment where team members can work together professionally and feel supported. We wish you all the best and thank you for your contributions during your time with us.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All