employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Western & Southern Financial Group

Engaged Employer

Stay as far away from HR as you can - Human Resources Generalist Western & Southern Financial Group Employee Review

2.0
Feb 14, 2015
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Rock solid financially, free breakfast and lunch, subsidized parking, generally friendly people, almost impossible to get fired (esp. if in a protected class), defined benefit pension, 401k with matching, health benefits in top 20% of local employers.

Cons

While there are a few good people at the lower/mid levels in HR, you should know that HR spends must of its time like a police force for violations of dress code. For females, every aspect of appearance is restricted like what kind of shoes you can wear, how high your heels can be, what color hose/stockings, length of skirt (must be at or below the knee), no cleavage, no revealing sweaters. For males, hair length, hair style, facial hair, clothing are all based on rules. Ties are required 364 days a year (one casual day per year. I think HR turnover was probably like 30%, but because the number is lumped in with stable groups like benefits, guard force and cafeteria, which report into HR, it looks much better than it is. If someone split out the true turnover number for HR, the CEO would probably freak. Organization is extremely hierarchical. Generally, if you talk to your boss's boss (in HR or elsewhere) you can get in major trouble. I saw few skip-levels unless there was a crisis. Worse, HR doesn't do talent management. It takes forever to move people out of the organization because of fear of lawsuits. This means loads of paperwork and butt-covering, so company is stuck with a huge percentage of low performers because who has time to go through the process? It's like pulling teeth to get low performers out. There's no turnover at the highest levels of company. Business heads get rotated around, even if they fail. Average age fo business heads is around 65-70. Most have no energy, no interest in what's happening in the outside world. I was told that at least one business head has been known to fall asleep during meetings. Ops, which I supported for a short while, is a gossip factory, with blame always falling to HR. The same leaders who have been their since the 90s watching the company shrink are still in charge in 2015. This same talenet management gap is throughout the organization with possible exception of Fort Washington. There is no talent management function in HR, and then leadership wonders why the company underperforms the industry for expenses, growth. Could it be that 20% of the org are below average performers? In addition to no talent management, there's no OD function in HR either. With no TM and no OD, you can imagine how stale the company has become. Which is why they spend their time as HR police, not strategic/value-added HR. If you want to learn something about a modern HR org, stay as far away from this group as you can. But if you want to learn how NOT to run HR, go ahead and join up.

Explore other reviews about Western & Southern Financial Group

2.0
Apr 8, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Located downtown, so very walkable. Optional pet insurance benefit is nice. They don't do layoffs, so very stable company to work for. An OK place to work at as a first job out of college. Provided daily lunch is sometimes really good.

Cons

The building has a roach infestation and they are spotted several times a month. Management tends to play favorites. One manager has been reported to HR multiple times by multiple people across many years for being too aggressive to the point several employees have had mental breakdowns, yet still retains their position. Dress code is business professional despite most never interacting with customers. No work from home at all. Company claims to be secular but very clearly has a Christian lean around Christmas time. Yearly raises do not keep up with inflation. Employees are told they are not to discuss their wages with each other, likely due to pay discrepancies between employees in the same roles.

1
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All