McMaster-Carr reviews

2.8

29% would recommend to a friend

(1,369 total reviews)

Jay Delaney

30% approve of CEO

45% positive business outlook

McMaster-Carr has an employee rating of 2.8 out of 5 stars, based on 1,369 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The McMaster-Carr employee rating is 24% below average for employers within the Construction, Repair & Maintenance Services industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

1K reviews
5.0
May 26, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I am so glad I did not let the negative reviews on this website stop me from taking this job. There *is* a huge difference between roles in the Systems department and roles in General Management. I worked in Systems. I worked as a software developer for more than two years and went from knowing nothing about applied software development to knowing enough to get a great next job in software. - Huge culture of learning and teaching in the department - Opportunity to learn about different domains (front-end, back-end, infrastructure, data science, security) while learning about how an industrial supply business functions. - Had two spectacular managers who took effort to spend time to help me grow - Had the opportunity to grow as a coder and as a communicator - Learned a lot about visual design - Surprisingly forward-thinking initiatives present around diversity and inclusion considering how old the company is. It's no Etsy / Stitch-Fix, but better than most companies from what I can tell. - The department uses some new technologies (languages, platforms, services), like a hot start-up, but has 0% of going bankrupt in 2 years, unlike a hot start-up. - The company prioritizes doing it right the first time instead of hacking things together perpetually forever. I learned a lot about technical debt here, and how to write sustainable code. If you love learning, teaching, sharing, and want to learn about software development in a medium-pressure environment, work here.

Cons

- Don't work in here if you're interested in user experience design / user psychology / customer interviews / marketing. They don't really do that like you think they do. - There are a few managers who are arrogant and act in sexist ways / don't make efforts to improve themselves with regard to inclusion / don't listen to their female employees equally, but they are in the minority. It's mostly dudes who don't see how their actions sustain a culture where it's harder for women to succeed. There's still a strong community of stellar women kicking a** at software development, though. They're just not currently represented in upper management.

1.0
May 24, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

You'll have a fair base pay. There are many wonderful and smart people among the worker bees, and you will make friends for life. Insurance is exceptional and is free - you pay nothing, however, I've heard this might change in the future. Profit sharing plan is pretty nice when the company does well, and would regularly provide 5-figure, cash payouts to all employees every December. Full/100% tuition reimbursement. No 401k, but the company has a trust where they give the employees prorated deposits each year. The catch is, you'll need to stay 5-6 years to receive the full payout when you leave the company. As a new employee, you are vested a certain percent each year until you’re fully entitled to all the money upon exiting.

Cons

McM is currently (and has been for a long time) a completely top-down environment where you will have minimal opportunity for career growth. It’s RARE that a “regular” office worker gets promoted into middle management. Regular workers will NEVER be promoted into upper management. As other reviews state, McM hires management trainees directly upon graduation from Ivy-league schools. You’ll have people in their early 20s with no corporate experience who are now managing regular, long-tenured employees who have been in the same position for 10, 15, or 20+ years. I mean, what could go wrong with that situation? Business decisions are made at a high (Director) level and you'll have little to no input for process improvement or process development. McM truly operates on a caste system. Additionally, they use proprietary legacy software that is a complete nightmare to use, and they have people in their Systems/IT department who were liberal arts majors in college and have no previous Systems experience - no joke. Turnover is nonsensically high, both voluntary and involuntary. Overnight, you can go from being a highly-regarded, exceptional employee to someone who is endlessly criticized over things that are non-issues in the real business world. Management plays favorites, and if you’re not a favorite it’s only a matter of time before they find a reason to fire you. I saw good, intelligent, and hard-working employees get reprimanded at annual reviews and eventually fired because they did something “wrong”. Alternately, I saw highly-favored employees who would do little else other than showing up on time be rewarded with a glowing annual review and pay increase. Your ROI upon leaving McM in regards to transferable skills is a joke. Hope you acquired a useful degree on their expense, or saved enough money from your annual bonuses to go back to school to acquire new skills and experience.

2.0
May 24, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

• Free tuition reimbursement (100% tuition+textbooks reimbursement in any subject from an accredited program as long as you get at least a D and no requirement to stay with the company) • You will never have work to do outside of work hours. • The medical and dental plans are amazing and you don't have to pay any premiums. • There is a cash bonus every year for anyone still employed on December 1st (last year each employee got a bonus of 480% of their monthly salary). • If you work in the warehouse: the people are great.

Cons

• Your job will probably be extremely boring, repetitive, and automated out of existence within 10 years. • If you work in the office: you don't really get opportunities to get to know anyone in the cubicles around you (if you're an introvert, this may be a Pro). • Career advancement decisions are made far removed from your own management team, and you don't really have any input. You may be spontaneously moved (horizontal "promotion") to a different department with 2 days notice. • You may have skills that the company needs, but they'd rather promote one of their management trainees (1st class McM citizens) into the role, rather than waste a good job on an office drone (2nd class McM citizens), or a warehouse worker (3rd class McM citizens). • The class structure mentioned in the above bulletpoint exists.

Viewing 853 - 855 of 1,369 Reviews

Glassdoor has 1,407 McMaster-Carr reviews submitted anonymously by McMaster-Carr employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if McMaster-Carr is right for you.