Menards reviews

3.5

63% would recommend to a friend

(7,000 total reviews)
avatar

John R. Menard Jr.

48% approve of CEO

57% positive business outlook

Menards has an employee rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars, based on 7,000 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Menards employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Retail & Wholesale industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

7K reviews
4.0
Feb 9, 2015
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Compensation is above average for the hourly wage earner. Initial starting wage is somewhat negotiable if you have prior retail experience. Additional pay is offered to those who work on the weekends. Every employee is offered a yearly bonus check based on years worked and hourly pay. Hours are very flexible for both part-time and full-time employees. The individual employee can usually decided the amount of hours and when they work (with a few caveats). Given the flexibility in regard to setting ones own schedule and extra pay on weekends this is great job to have while attending college. Both department and store level management is easy to work with (for the most part). If the individual employee is self motivated and hard working management gives them the freedom to work without being micro-managed. Management does acknowledge those who possess a good work ethic and those that do things that are beyond what is expected of them.

Cons

The work environment and daily experiences are typical of a large retail corporation. The work done on a daily basis is very monotonous. Sustained positive motivation is difficult to maintain because at the end of the day there is nothing to show for the hard work and effort one has put in (especially when you will be doing the same thing the very next day, day-in and day-out). Those who have a good work ethic end up picking up the slack of those who do not (which is typical in any job but extremely pervasive in the retail setting). When hard working individuals are promoted and/or poor workers are finally let go management takes a very long time to replace those individuals with new hires leading to severe under staffing of key positions for lengthy periods of time. When part-time/full-time hourly employees try to follow company policy (when a customer is unhappy with it) upper-level management will usually undermine the policy to please the customer which in-turn leaves the hourly employee out on a limb and looking like a fool in the eyes of customers and fellow employees (this can be very frustrating and demoralizing). Hourly employees will encounter individuals within both lower-level and upper-level management that have the tendency to micro-manage their employees. This can be demoralizing and frustrating (especially when it gets in the way of the employee doing their job effectively and efficiently). Attendance policy is huge problem when it comes to the part-time hourly employee. There is a point system that is completely unforgiving and extremely patronizing which adversely effects part-time hourly employees.

3.0
Feb 6, 2015
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Average Hourly pay, with plenty of opportunities for overtime in most markets. Can make manager with no college requirements. Relocation available in all markets. Holiday pay for full time employees, vacation, Instant Profit Sharing based on annual pretax income, which can increase yearly in a snow ball effect. 401k offered as well as insurance and dental. Great people to work with. Very customer "guest" focused. Huge selection of products to sell. No longer utilizes individual employee contract agreements. Head of Operations is a man with years of in store GM experience and connects well with the needs of store level employees. I enjoy his leadership more then previous Heads.

Cons

Hundreds of policy and procedures to know, many of which can be vague and ambiguous and open to GM interpretation. Odd management hours for department managers along with working every other weekend. Every weekend if you are part time. It takes 10 years of full time employment to hit max 4 weeks of vacation. Hamstrung on where you can buy certain building materials goods, making competition difficult against more agile competitors. Once heard an HR upper manager state "Menards does not care about your family life" in regards to relocation to save a marriage. Constant turn over in part time employees makes retention and continuity hard in departments. Overwhelming amount of reports. Micromanagement is the norm. No 401k matching. Insurance is expensive even with company contribution. Commercial/Contractor sales is the bane of the owners existence and is watched under microscope from WI. Threatens financial recourse if you quit to work for a competitor within 24 months and so many miles.

4.0
Feb 6, 2015

Menards

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Menards teaches great sales techniques, teamwork, and a positive sales atmosphere.

Cons

Pay was not great, benefits were expensive.

Viewing 6484 - 6486 of 7,000 Reviews

Glassdoor has 7,159 Menards reviews submitted anonymously by Menards employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Menards is right for you.