employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

American Arbitration Association

Is this your company?

American Arbitration Association reviews

3.6

67% would recommend to a friend

(132 total reviews)

India Johnson

69% approve of CEO

59% positive business outlook

American Arbitration Association has an employee rating of 3.6 out of 5 stars, based on 132 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The American Arbitration Association employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Nonprofit & NGO industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

132 reviews
1.0
Jan 23, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The people in the department are great to work with and share years of experience freely. Work life balance is incredible, 37.5 hour work week with occasional mandatory paid overtime.

Cons

Management varies from different divisions and offices so my views are related to the NYICMC office. NYICMC’s management is detached with the day to day operations. Most managers have not worked a caseload in many years and upper management have never done so. The majority of decisions are made from the top down without any opinions or feedback from employees who work directly with the clients. Employee morale is extremely low and many in various departments are looking to leave. Currently, turnover is low but would change once the economy picks up. Upper management’s mentality must be oblivious to the morale as they still continue to say, “if you are not happy you are free to leave” at meetings. Even though there have not been any salary increases for the past 4, managers still expect employees to go above and beyond. Corporate management may be better but from the discussions and interactions I had with them, it does not seem so. I would suggest if you are looking for a place to grow, AAA is not the company you go to. Supervisors and managers are rarely hired/promoted for their competency. Salaries are lower compared to the private sector with no benefits to balance it out.

5.0
Jul 25, 2025

I love it here!

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I really do. Recently was hired and been here about a month and I couldn’t be happier. I came from a job with little benefits and minimal compensation increases. I do not feel that way about this company. They are going to contribute to paying off my student loans after 3 months of employment, insurance starts 30 days from start, the pay is good and a 403B. As an adult looking forward to retiring before I’m dead, I’m pretty happy with the position I have The work is straight forward. If you are teachable, willing to learn and able to take constructive criticism, you’ll be fine. The system they use to manage their cases is very old but has modern features. Overall, just learning how PRISM (their computer system) works and you’ll be fine. If you can’t, just keep bothering your supervisor for more one on one training or go to HR and they can help find someone to teach you The culture is so refreshing. There is definitely a feel that “no one wants to work overtime, we’re all here for a paycheck but hey, let make this a positive experience for all of us” I have not meet anyone who even gave an inkling of spite, bitterness or toxicity.

Cons

I agree. The training is very…dry. It’s difficult to understand the system and easy to make a mistake. You don’t have your own cases, you work tasks within a colleague’s case. If you make a mistake, you can end up making another person look bad, confuse the parties and other administrators. Additionally, you administrator the entire process of a case so there is so much information, it becomes overwhelmingly difficult to feel the progression. Again, you need to ask for help and be willing to accept it when offered.

Viewing 25 - 27 of 132 Reviews

Glassdoor has 138 American Arbitration Association reviews submitted anonymously by American Arbitration Association employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if American Arbitration Association is right for you.