You are Not in Good Hands - Customer Service Representative (CSR) Allstate Employee Review

1.0
Dec 3, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I have no pros for this company.

Cons

You are in bad hands from start to finish. You change managers frequently so that by the time you reach your annual review you may have a manager that has only spoke to you just a bit. Aggressive leadership principals. If you are not a leader you are punished. Your on the phone metrics are only 50 percent of what they use to determine your raises. You can be perfect on the phone and if you are not a leader or you are but your manager does not write it all down and they conveniently move you to a new manager who "I can only judge you by what I personally see." The leadership principals have this effect: They keep you in your place. You are good enough to keep in your role but not good enough to pay more too. 2.5 years I worked and never got a raise. Allstate is terrible to their agents and I have never spoken to so many angry agents in my life. And they have reason. Allstate competes against their captive agents. If you get a quote at the agency and a quote directly from Allstate the direct quote is cheaper. Allstate justifies this by saying they are saving on premiums. The agencies are in bad hands too. Not a trade secret. Just get two quotes with identical things. Allstate has discrimination. I was discriminated against. I stupidly filed a complaint with HR. HR talked to my manager and told the manager of the complaint. They informed me that she was receptive of the feedback. They kept me on the team with this manager. The incident was in mid September. The manager wrote my review in January. If there wasn't a measured metric they lied. I filed a complaint of retaliation. Too much time passed for retaliation I was told. Oh and they fire you if you give a notice that you are going to a competitor even though it turns out that Allstate sends some policies to that competitor.

Explore other reviews about Allstate

5.0
Jun 29, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Work life balance - Opportunities to grow - Great leadership - Challenging yet rewarding work - Open to new ideas and positive changes

Cons

- Partial knowledge gap when it comes to technology

5.0
Jul 15, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Schedule is 10 on 4 off which is better than most carriers CAT pay (commission) is just fair and not difficult to acquire so you can rely on it consistently. Very helpful and patient work environment.

Cons

Can be a lot of work just have to make sure to stay on top of it so it doesn’t build up I would say the hours can range from 6-12 a day

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All