Dream Job with a few small hiccups - Commodity Manager American Airlines Employee Review

5.0
Nov 20, 2015
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

American offers a competitive salary with excellent benefits (free non-rev (standby) unlimited flying in coach, confirmed tickets at 20% discount of the stated fare, superb and comprehensive health insurance, reasonable vacation time, 5.5% 401k match after 1 year) There isnt a glass ceiling. You can move in the department or across departments and there is room for advancement (based on merit). American leadership is solid, I really believe we have a competent and caring executive team ( as well as other lower level management) that is legitimately interested to hear about its employees interests and concerns. A considerable amount of transparency. American also payed my relocation expenses (professional moving company) when I moved and gave me a (taxable) moving/house hunting stipend of about $1300. American (at least in our department, though I would say in most others as well) gives plenty of opportunity for work life balance.

Cons

Poor IT infrastructure: the internet is slow, you have to provide your own monitors at work (as well as any decent mice or keyboards) Conference rooms and other common spaces are rather inadequate. Per diem is $30/day or actual expenses when traveling for work Unpaid vacation is not an option The cafeteria food is OK but certainly not budget conscious with limited (and slowly improving) variety, No free snacks and the break rooms are minimal and antiquated (expected to change when a new headquarters is built) No on-site gym or shower facilities

Explore other reviews about American Airlines

5.0
Jul 13, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great career worth the process

Cons

Hiring process takes a bit be patient

2.0
Jul 13, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

There are some truly wonderful people at American. Many care deeply about aviation and have a calling for what they do. The diversity is outstanding. The industry is endlessly fascinating. You are always learning.

Cons

Sadly, the toxicity of my department after we were reorganized. It turned a job I loved into one I dreaded. And management looked the other way while a steady stream of talent exited through the revolving door. I would have done nearly anything for the company. Politics, pettiness and a "mean girls" culture destroyed morale, and the negative behavior was only rewarded. PTO allowance is cheap, making flight benefits great only on paper for your first 5 years of employment.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All