employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

American Eagle Outfitters

Is this your company?

After 17 years in retail this company was a joke - Associate Store Manager American Eagle Outfitters Employee Review

2.0
Nov 13, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Sales associates and merch staff were awesome, fun, hard working people. Was a fun, energetic place to work when the big bosses weren’t there. Clothes are nice.

Cons

Unrealistic expectations of management. With the new payroll model a manager is expected to run a high volume store with a skeleton staff and be a sales person, cashier, fitting room attendant, and floor manager all at once with 200-400 footsteps per hour. Also while expected to do associate assessments, manager assessments, coaching, developing, and following up with division of responsibility. Favoritism is showed by upper management. In my building specifically towards those who were Latin. You can get written up for doing something that every other manager has done and admitted to if you aren’t on their good side or are being targeted. Upper management only wants yes men and doesn’t like to hear different approaches or about what’s not working. Says they develop their people but I personally saw 3 managers thrown in a high volume store with literally no training at all, two of which have never been managers before. Schedule is ridiculous, expected long hours in retail but the following weeks schedule was posted a day and a half before the new week which never allowed for any type of planning of work life balance. Weekends off are almost non existent even though during the interview process they say it’s rotating every 4 weeks. I went 12 weeks without a weekend off and I’m pretty sure other managers went even longer. If you are not performing in your position, the mentoring you will receive consist of a paper telling you what you need to improve on and that’s it, no partnerships, no help, no advice, no touch bases, just “do better”.

Explore other reviews about American Eagle Outfitters

5.0
Apr 21, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Very supportive management and flexibility

Cons

You have more opportunities for shifts on weekdays

4.0
Jul 21, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Positive environment, great management, warm and welcoming team, cute clothes, amazing employee discount program.

Cons

Often not enough hours given to properly staff, hectic during back-to-school / holidays / black friday. Doesn't pay well enough for the amount of work required. Sales associate pay is low, so only very young people become associates, and they are slow and not so competent at getting stuff done around the store, so the majority of labor falls on managers. And we aren't paid enough.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All