employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Insomnia Cookies

Is this your company?

Company cares more about their money than their employees - Shift Leader Insomnia Cookies Employee Review

2.0
Aug 31, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Pay was pretty solid for the job. Started out as a baker at $9.50, then $11 as a shift leader, and even had three 50 cent raises with another one due in September. Free cookie per shift and half off all products. Benefits are offered to certain employees. Some of these include health, vision, and dental insurance, along with 401k. Some of the employees were great to work with.

Cons

Some of the employees were bad to work with, and management didn't seem to care about the repeated complaints from customers and fellow employees. As long as the store opened and cookies were sold they could not have cared less about our store. Very corporate. Security system is installed and monitored at all times, with the excuse being for the safety of the employees. 99% of the time this led to documentation of a worker doing something the company didn't want them to do, such as checking the schedule not in uniform. I personally don't see an issue with this but I guess it is an issue to them. Honestly, it felt like we were set up to fail. Example: our freezer could barely hold the minimum number of supplies we were required to order, so on truck days we always had to do something we weren't supposed to do, such as putting boxes on the ground in the freezer. When we asked management what to do in that situation, we were told, "You need to find a way to make it all fit." Speaking of truck days, we had to carry each box by hand from outside into the store, while somehow watching the store. I have no idea how we were expected to reasonably do this, since the truck always showed up almost two hours before the second employee got to the store. Anytime the company can cut hours, they will. They actually tried to implement a new policy for each September that states any employee may only work three shifts a week. This was made to counteract the high turnover rate of employees that each store goes through every fall, but all it would really end up doing is punish the long-time employees. Thankfully, they ended up changing this policy before it went live, but it's a very recent example of how this company only cares about their money. As a shift leader, you'd think I was in a supervisor position, but I held no actual authority to really do anything. It felt like if anything went wrong, I was there to take the blame, and that's the purpose of having designated shift leaders. It felt like a fancy job title where they pay you more because you may get documented for something you have no control over. Also, if other employees repeatedly break rules and you ask them to stop (such as not wearing a uniform, leaving their bike in the store lobby, etc.) they usually times do not because you don't have any actual authority. However, if upper management finds out they're breaking these rules, the shift leader also gets reprimanded. I was literally laughed at by a biker once when I informed him we are not allowed to keep our bikes in the store lobby. Thanks for having my back, management!

Explore other reviews about Insomnia Cookies

5.0
Jun 28, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Boss is very chill/laid-back Easy work

Cons

Corporate over, reaches and comes up with dumb policies Pay isn’t amazing

4.0
Apr 27, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

One of the few companies that are fully operational during the “night owl” hours. The cookies are absolutely delicious, and employees are encouraged to try them all and share the cookie bounty! Staff was incredibly friendly and diversified, and management was available and approachable. Stores are well organized, everything is labeled and within easy reach, making every shift run smoother

Cons

Employees should be given more training, especially drivers commuting from other parts of town. There are “guidelines” (aka rules) posted everywhere and it was a little excessive, which may be more indicative of the times we live in, though.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All