employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Jewelers Mutual Group

Engaged Employer

Went downhill fast - Personal Lines Representative Jewelers Mutual Group Employee Review

2.0
Jan 13, 2020
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Cafeteria, co-workers, park-like location, pay, benefits

Cons

Management, unrealistic metrics, awful turnaround. Many good employees have been let go with literally no reason given. The managers in PL don’t like it when people have a voice of their own, particularly in regards to how they are running things. One of the “submitted questions” to the CEO was “why is PL turnaround so high?” And the employee who wrote it was let go not even 2 days after. Management implemented unrealistic metrics in 2017 and the PL department had gone downhill ever since. Adherence, after-call, all the typical call center nonsense. As a call center employee you are also expected to remember an outrageous amount of information when speaking to customers and if you forget even the dumbest little thing you get talked to. Basically treating us like children instead of responsible adults. This used to be a great company to work for back in late 2016, early 2017. Now their turnaround is high and everyone is unhappy, at least in PL.

avatar
Jewelers Mutual Group Response
6y
JM is proud of our Customer Care professionals and see them as critical to delivering on our customer commitments. We’re excited about recent changes that have resulted in positive morale, lower employee turnover, and 2019 above average engagement scores. Leaders continue to prioritize their talent, look for process improvements, and celebrate results under the leadership of our Jeweler’s Mutual Executive Team. Individual feedback, questions and/or perception are encouraged, and can be directed to a JM’s HR team member.

Explore other reviews about Jewelers Mutual Group

5.0
Jun 2, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

A strong company with a long history of success. Jewelers Mutual is full of curious and collaborative people that want to see others and the company succeed. I have never been part of such a supportive organization.

Cons

Fast moving company so sometimes it would be beneficial if we slowed down.

2.0
Jul 8, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good benefits like 401k match and a decent amount of PTO

Cons

Career advancement and compensation reviews appear to be extremely limited, even when employees take on substantially expanded responsibilities and perform work well beyond their original job descriptions. Managers who attempt to advocate for title changes or salary adjustments face significant resistance, making meaningful discussions about employee growth difficult to have. While the same people keep getting promoted.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All