It was great, until it wasn't. - Marketing PENNYMAC Employee Review

1.0
Jan 19, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

There are some fantastic people on the team. For years, I genuinely liked going into the office and working with those around me.

Cons

As the company scaled, the culture shifted significantly. Expectations and workloads increased, but support at the lower levels did not keep pace. Additionally, compensation is notably lower than industry competitors, with annual raises typically capped around 2-3% - if they occur at all. This combination of high pressure and low reward led to a culture of micromanagement where creativity was often stifled in favor of unattainable standards. Many of the design, writing and other staff suffered from creative fatigue due to an excessive amount of edits and constant hovering. Instead of being encouraged to innovate, creative minds were squashed by a process (or lack of a process) where nothing felt good enough, leading to a sharp decline in morale. The most concerning shift, however, was the toxicity in mid to upper management. I witnessed (and experienced) managers speaking disparagingly about employees to their peers, which devastated trust. Why would I want to perform for somebody that is just going to trash me behind closed doors? This high stress environment eventually became unsustainable, affecting both professional performance and personal well being. From my understanding, these issues are still happening today based on accounts from former colleagues who remain in touch with current staff. It is very disappointing. The company has the potential to be as great as they claim, but the current environment says otherwise. They will pitch you on a lot of 'perks,' but no perk could make me want to return. Since leaving, I have found a new love for work again in an environment where I am actually appreciated and heard. I sat on making this review for a long time, but I suppose it could be beneficial for anyone looking at Pennymac for a future career so you know what to expect if you do choose to go down this road.

avatar
PENNYMAC Response
4mo
We are sorry to hear about your experience in our workplace. We assure you that it is never our intention to create a stressful work environment for any of our employees. However, we appreciate you sharing your feedback with us, as it allows us to improve and make necessary changes for the benefit of our team members. We want to emphasize that we value the well-being of our employees. We understand that everyone operates differently and have personalized needs, and we try our best to accommodate those needs while still accomplishing our business goals. Nevertheless, we are continually looking for ways to make our workplace more amenable, so employees can come to work feeling fulfilled and engaged. Our company aims to learn from past mistakes and find better solutions because of them. Thank you for taking the time to write this review, and we wish you the very best in your future endeavors. If you decide you want to express more, please feel free to email our team: employeerelations@pennymac.com

Explore other reviews about PENNYMAC

5.0
Nov 18, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Amazing people and great culture

Cons

My drive to work is long but its is a great place to work so it is worth the drive.

avatar
PENNYMAC Response
6mo
Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts on our company. We appreciate your honest feedback along with the pros and cons you mentioned. Our company values open communication, and we take your advice seriously. We will continue to listen to our employees' feedback and work towards improving our communication channels. Once again, thank you for your honest feedback, and we look forward to continuing to learn and grow with you.
1.0
Jun 2, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good team and good cafeteria

Cons

-micromanagement heaven -you want a promotion? Too bad a DEI hire from outside the company is going to take it instead -they love pulling the rug from under you with a new comp plan “to match industry standards”. -they treat their processors like they’re kids in a sweat shop so the processors have no incentive to care about your file (they give them peanuts as a quarterly bonus) -they have RCT spies to watch everything you do and snitch to your manager/ set your lunches / decide if your time is approved -they act like it’s the best place to work but it’s absolutely not

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All