A Company Trying to be New School with Old School Toxicity - Business Control Specialist PENNYMAC Employee Review

2.0
Sep 8, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

There's hybrid flexibility for most roles. I would say the pay is decent. Work-life balance is ok to a point. There is some attempt at employee engagement but I did not see a lot in my time there.

Cons

There was a major focus on production for my role, which was not clearly defined as a production role when I agreed to the position. Loans reviewed per hour are heavily scrutinized by management in order to maximize employee productivity. Failing to hit a certain number per hour meant that an employee would be reprimanded for productivity. The department's ultimate goal is to have a team of 2 to 3 employees do as much as possible within a workday, rather than employing the appropriate number of employees to handle the workload. The end result is employees become micromanaged to ensure that a rigid production schedule is met that isn't necessary and can be obtained by other means. When the workload is very heavy, other departments are often recruited to help disposition files. As one may have guessed, the end result is that many arbitrary errors are found when the files are reviewed. There is no consistency about what the job is meant to be or how day-to-day processes should be conducted between frontline employees, middle management, and top management. Front-line specialists may have. completely different understanding of how certain scenarios should be handled than management. Because of this, new employees may become frustrated or confused because of the different answers that may receive when asking questions. Management lacks actual managerial skills and many are in leadership roles due to being high producers in their past positions. This is a common trope within the mortgage industry, and it would even seem like an appropriate idea if managers were expected to produce just as their subordinates are. However, this is not the case. Managers in this department are strictly salaried supervisors and their expectations are to lead, coach, and give feedback. Since they were promoted for past production and not their potential to motivate and influence employees, they lack the necessary skills to accomplish their intended goal. The end result is that there is a hyper-fixation on production with little to no feedback detailing how to improve or a realistic view that some days production can vary. Essentially middle management views their position as literal micromanagement, leading to a toxic work culture. From personal experience, not only was my hourly production monitored closely, but my emails were monitored by management to ensure screenshots looked appropriate. There are also times when I was reprimanded for not answering an email quickly enough, even when the email had been received within 30 minutes and not marked as urgent. Not only is severe micromanagement an issue, but some managers have no way to conduct themselves in the office. My manager made a habit of frequent inappropriate remarks/stories. These ranged from stories of drug use to a remark made regarding a physical I had requested PTO for.

Explore other reviews about PENNYMAC

5.0
Apr 28, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Room to grow and take responsibilities

Cons

Direction from management and work culture.

avatar
PENNYMAC Response
2mo
Thank you for taking the time to provide your honest feedback about your experience with our company. We are delighted to hear that you enjoyed working with us in your capacity and appreciated the friendly work surroundings. Indeed, we believe that a positive work/life culture is a crucial aspect of any successful business, and we are glad that you recognized our efforts in this regard. We are always willing to learn from our employees' experiences and suggestions. Therefore, we will continue to monitor the working environment, listen carefully to feedback, and make any improvements necessary. Thank you for being a part of our team, and we look forward to continuing our positive working relationship with you.
2.0
Jun 17, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Training was always provided and you were never rushed to learn. Snacks were given on a daily basis. You had a Penny Pantry in the building that offered free coffee/Soda and a variety of food selections at a resonable price.

Cons

Low paying position at $22.00 an hour to start with no increases. The department couldnt find other Loan Specialist for the longest time and then increased the position to $27.oo an hour in an effort to attract more people. Four of the employees that were already there for a few years in the department were allowed to work remotely on Thursdays and Fridays, every new Employee had to work on site. Bonus was paid a month and a week after the quarter, so March's bonus was given to you on May 7! Human Resources lied and was extremely unprofessional, when challenged they offered no response or made up false information. My recommendation after being rehired and resigned, is to run in the opposite direction, and dont look back.

avatar
PENNYMAC Response
3w
Thank you for taking the time to share your review of your experience with us. We appreciate your candid perspective, and we're glad to hear you found value in our training programs and appreciated our daily office surroundings and pantry resources. We completely understand that compensation, benefit costs, and clear policy transparency are top priorities. We hear your frustrations regarding how starting pay adjustments, localized remote schedules, and incentive timelines can impact the day-to-day experience. We constantly review our compensation structures and internal procedures to ensure fairness, remaining competitive in the market while balancing our overall team dynamics. Regarding your feedback on our communication, we take your comments very seriously. Our company deeply values open communication, and it is never our intention to create an environment where an employee feels unheard or unsupported. We are continuously evaluating ourselves to learn from our employees' experiences and improve our management practices. Even if we cannot change the past, we are genuinely driven to influence the future. Because you have the unique perspective of having spent time with us across multiple tenures, we invite you to reach out directly to our corporate human resources team at employeerelations@pennymac.com. We want to listen carefully to your feedback and ensure your specific insights are thoroughly noted as part of our continuous improvement strategy. We value your time with the team, and we wish you the very best in your future endeavors.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All