Benefits are great- and that's about it - Shift Supervisor Sheetz Employee Review

3.0
Jul 3, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good benefits, CEO is actually great guy and so is the family, Flexibility in location

Cons

Shady practices and favoritism with HR and management to remove people they do not like or promote people they do, Hours will never be what you expect or want if you are full time, management positions overlap - as a supervisor you will end up doing most management duties without the pay or benefits of being an assistant, turnover rate is terrible, ALWAYS short staffed and expected to pick up the slack. Most stores have ill equipped or overall inadequate upper management. Personally, I've been with the company a couple years- always praised on work ethic and ability- but am always stuck doing the hours and positions the store needs- not what I want or have earned. If you are good at your job or care about it at all- you will be inadvertently punished because the work and expectations will fall on your shoulders- and you will get absolutely nothing for it unless it benefits the store/company. Corporate created amazing training program but stores are too short staffed and not given appropriate hours/mgmt does not stick to the plan in order to ensure training properly. Tons of advancement opportunities but no development if it doesn't suit them. I am looking for another job because I've waited nearly the entire length of my employment to be developed into and the chance to be assistant management or even just a first shift supervisor. I've gotten neither- despite positive performance reviews.

avatar
Sheetz Response
8y
I’m sorry to hear that your experience with Sheetz has not been a good one. We are proud that the vast majority of our staff enjoy a happy and fulfilling career with us. That said, as hard as we try to get it right all of the time there will be times we fall short. We encourage our staff to give us feedback through their manager and through employee surveys, so we can continue to learn and improve the way we work. Please feel free to contact me to receive your feedback in more detail and give us a chance to change your perception.

Explore other reviews about Sheetz

5.0
Jul 22, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great job like a lot

Cons

Busy very very busy love it

avatar
Sheetz Response
3d
Thanks for helping us making Sheetz happen! We appreciate the time and hustle you gave to Sheetz. Thanks for the review!
3.0
Jul 22, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Barely competitive pay and good benefits

Cons

Cult like structure, there's no accountability and team building. Just favoritism or who can cause problems the least for management. Once you start promoting into management. It's pretty cut throat and gets worse the higher you go

avatar
Sheetz Response
3d
We'd love to follow up with you about your experience and the location you worked at. We never want to hear about favoritism or issues within the team. Please feel free to reach out to our Employee Relations team at 1-800-280-4357 to share more about your experience.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All