Menards reviews

3.5

64% would recommend to a friend

(6,994 total reviews)
avatar

John R. Menard Jr.

49% approve of CEO

57% positive business outlook

Menards has an employee rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars, based on 6,994 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Menards employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Retail & Wholesale industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

7K reviews
2.0
Aug 18, 2017

Terrible work/life balance for management

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Co-workers were wonderful and developed many life long friendships with fellow managers, Profit sharing checks in February were amazing after being with the company for over 8 years. Pay was decent. Many guests were cool and you really develop great report with the regulars. Full-time or Part-time team members have it pretty easy, very little accountability, so if you're a fan of dumping easy guest questions on your manager and hiding from said guests, this is the job for you.

Cons

Closing and then opening (clopening as we liked to call it) left you drained. Very little sleep often less than 5 hours. Sundays I was required to work open to close (yes that's 730 AM to 8 PM) and we would NEVER be allowed to leave at close, some nights required to stay an additional 45 mins to an hour. Never ending piles of freight, Upper management seems to do little to help the store (couldn't be bothered to even face end caps or clean up register areas) Hard to motivate team members to work very hard when the store management is seen chatting with their favorite department managers for hours at a time. While upper management wasn't very helpful with assisting in store tasks (when they see understaffed department managers struggling) they are quick to watch the cameras to call anyone out who takes a few moments to rest their weary bodies and minds towards the end of yet another 12 hour shift. So tired on your days off that you literally sleep most of the day. Getting off of work so late that you are unable to have any type of social or family life. Being sexually harassed by scuzzy contractors (whistled at, asked out, out-right ogled etc.) God forbid the other manager in your department take vacation because guess what? You'll be working 6 days/60 hours that week. Regular work weeks during our "not busy time" I was averaging 45-48 hours in 5 days. No sick days, so come to work while you are ill otherwise you are putting added stress on the other manager because now they are getting called into work on their only day off. This is not a healthy/sustainable lifestyle of anyone. I could only manage 3 years of management before I realized that there was no way I could do this for the rest of my life.

1.0
Feb 28, 2015
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

It’s a good place to work PT while going to school or as a 2nd job PT as they pay above minimum wage and give you schedule flexibility. Overall, it’s an easy job if you have common sense and a good work ethic. Instant Profit Sharing (IPS) is really the only good benefit they have. They offered an employee discount, weekend pay increase, and gave out holiday gifts. FT got every other weekend off which is better than working every weekend. Pet & Grocery Specialist had a set schedule unlike other non-management FT positions. A lot of career opportunities and easy to move up if you're willing to work. A lot of my co-workers and department managers were cool and easy to get along with, but some co-workers acted like they were in high school by creating drama and back stabbing other co-workers.

Cons

Overall, Menards is a dead end job unless you advance into corporate. The working environment was hostile, negative, & stressful which led to low morale & workers just doing the bare minimum. There were blatant examples of favoritism, fraternization, verbal abuse of employees by customers & co-workers, state/local laws being broken, and OSHA laws being ignored. Management was ran by people with no degrees or any knowledge of business what so ever. Managers rarely held anyone accountable for their actions or mistakes. They were either one to all of the following: on a power trip, rude & unprofessional, young & inexperienced, lazy, lacking leadership, no business sense, played favorites, provided no direction, and didn’t appreciate their employees’ hard work. The negatives outweigh the positives for moving into management. Management has to work 55+ hrs every week, must relocate stores to move up, and follow ridiculous policies & rules from corporate, no thanks. Corporate micromanages everything by stores visits and spying on employees using the cameras in the store. They used the fear of losing your job to motivate employees & demotion to punish them. Corporate was out of touch with reality on the daily operations of a store by the suggestions they made during visits & the tasks they assigned. The policies & procedures changed constantly & were vague and open to interpretation by managers. As a result, there was never a consensus on how anything was to be done which led to much confusion. Corporate also had set up some of the craziest, write up happy rules I have ever seen for a workplace. The point system for enforcing these rules was ridiculous. Training was a learn on the fly style with little to no direction and an in-home training program with info for a 1st grade level instead of a 12th grade level. They played musical chairs with the staff, so no one knew anything about the department they worked in. All this led to terrible customer service & poorly runned stores. The stores are understaffed due to high turnover & low store payroll. This led to the overworking of employees and them trying to keep you after you’re done with your shift & tasks. It seemed the more hours you put in is more important than the quality of work done in their eyes. The scheduling program is flawed and would have you work 8-10 days in a row & 10+ hour shifts. FT must have an open schedule meaning a no work/life balance. Their technology & equipment is severely outdated and constantly breaking down. Benefits stink such as expensive health insurance that covers little, no 401K match, and too few vacation days.

1.0
Feb 12, 2018

Manager Trainee

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Customers experience fabulous, even extravagent customer service. I was instantly seduced, and declared, “I want to work in a place like this!” Wrong! Without Menards one, good trait, I never would have been allowed to rack up 3 to 5 WRITTEN commendations per week at any other retail org. 3rd week got: Best retail experience EVER! I had a blast doing this.

Cons

Ask about turnover. It says it all. 243%. That is not a typo. A 300 employee store needs 729 bodies to replace all the disgruntled newbs that quit in disgust EACH YEAR! I was one of 12 the week I was hired. Customers volunteered that they once worked at Menards years before. As a manager trainee, I decided to take an informative poll. Why did you leave? I have never heard of a large group of random people ever give the exact, same answer to ANY question before. “Management sucks!” was the universal reply. My manager hated me. A career man of 17 years, he knew how to play the game. He NEVER got commendations as a result. I lasted 21 days. Managment ran out of a sale item BEFORE the sale even started. HUNDREDS of angry customers milling around the store when my Sunday shift started. Read about all the pollution they get nailed for. It is far worse in reality. Read about owner John Menard. None of the articles seem exaggerated in any way, sad to say, personal AND professional behavior is sadly deficient for a leader of America’s 3rd largest home improvement chain. Er, wait a minute. They sell milk and greeting cards?!? Will you ever last long enough to collect your retirement? Bwahahahahahah! Dream on, babe! But hey, YOU might be the one to change it ALL around... Not holding MY breath. Company tried to swindle me out of a measly $10 bucks for a duplicate W2. I pointed out that since I never GOT my copy, I was only asking that they forward my returned one. Don’t expect a refund on your mandatory tool kit when you leave however... Just sayin’ New York to keep Glassdoor from letting them find and sue me. Very litigious company. Google that too!

Viewing 7 - 9 of 6,994 Reviews

Glassdoor has 7,153 Menards reviews submitted anonymously by Menards employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Menards is right for you.