Menards reviews

3.5

64% would recommend to a friend

(6,997 total reviews)
avatar

John R. Menard Jr.

49% approve of CEO

58% positive business outlook

Menards has an employee rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars, based on 6,997 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Menards employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Retail & Wholesale industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

7K reviews
2.0
Oct 26, 2011
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Easy and pretty laid back Quick advancement if willing to relocate out of state Looks good on your resume (kinda)

Cons

Must be willing to relocate out of state for advancement. Menards support on relocating is $1.00 raise and will contribute to half a U-Haul, and 3-4 nights in a hotel. If you have a college degree this program is a joke. You will be underpaid. You will not learn anything. You literally will have to commit to more than 45 hrs a week even if you get promoted all the way up to General Manager. "Retail Hours" typically 6:30am to 10pm. Every week your schedule will be different. A majority of the managers and higher-ups have no college education. So it can be sometimes difficult to communicate and you can expect them to make many mistakes. Raises. ""a joke"" you get a .10 ""cents"" raise every 6 months of employment and you max out at $2.50. (So for example you currently make $11.50hr. and after you have worked for 12.5 years you get $14hr.) (note that doesn't include promotion raises)

2.0
Sep 3, 2010
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Working in corporate you get a lot of experience and a lot of responsibility right away. This has helped me impress my employers after my time at Menards. It was also nice traveling to different parts of the country (even if it was just the Midwest).

Cons

-Having no social life due to the 50-70 hour work weeks (and that was just at an entry level position!). -Working every third weekend which made 6 days a week of working -Management pours the workload on you and everyone becomes stressed out which creates a not very high morale surrounding. When we were asked why we weren't making our deadlines - we would say because we have too much work to do, and have been working until 7-11pm every night and coming in on the weekends to try to make deadlines. But they didn't think that was a good enough reason. -Horribly expensive health benefits -Takes forever to build up a good amount of vacation time -Raises consist of 10 cents every 6 months - if you pass a test -News has traveled on how people are unhappy (at least in a Merchandise Planner position) so it takes 3 or more months to fill vacancies.

2.0
Feb 6, 2009
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I worked at the General Office of Menards as an analyst for several years before going leaving to obtain my MBA. Through my employment with Menards I gained great knowledge of business strategy. Being the underdog seems to put a scrappy spirit into maximizing revenue opportunities at the lowest cost - and this mentality is pervasive in the company. I would definitely recommend Menards for a person who is willing to put in a lot of hours and hard work to advance a career. If you plan on getting an advanced degree, use the opportunity as a stepping stone - you will take a lot of great knowledge away from this experience. If you do not plan on getting more education, Menards is a company that values competence and hard work over formal education, so there is really no ceiling from an educational perspective.

Cons

The biggest downside in my time there was work/life balance. Almost every position required some weekend work, and you were expected to average 50+ hours per week (in the general office most people worked much more than that) The pay structure at the analyst level is a bit low in the first few years, especially the week to week pay. Everything is hourly (at a very low rate), but with everyone working 55+ hours, the overtime makes the paycheck large enough to live on. Profit sharing and another bonus incentive ramp up after a few years, but until then you really are under-compensated. I admired the culture of hard work at Menards, but the overall talent level of the company is lacking. In my new position my group has mostly PhDs and MBAs, and the quality of analysis is light years ahead of Menards. Some other nit-picky things I didn't like (but may have changed since I left) were the requirements that vacation had to be taken a week at a time (instead of just using a vacation day at a time), internet and outside email access strictly controlled (I had to use a kiosk in the hall to check competitors' websites - there were two computers that could access the internet to send emails), and a certain tension in the office from people scared to make a mistake that could get them fired (to get your performance incentive bonus you had to sign a contract stating that Menards can fire you at any time for any reason - a clause they used rather often)

Viewing 196 - 198 of 6,997 Reviews

Glassdoor has 7,156 Menards reviews submitted anonymously by Menards employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Menards is right for you.