The Motley Fool reviews

2.3

14% would recommend to a friend

(303 total reviews)
avatar

Tom Gardner

24% approve of CEO

14% positive business outlook

The Motley Fool has an employee rating of 2.3 out of 5 stars, based on 303 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The The Motley Fool employee rating is 38% below average for employers within the Information Technology industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

303 reviews
2.0
Feb 26, 2016
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Compared to traditional finance companies, the Fool is a low key place to work. No need to dress up or wear a tie. Everyone, even the CIO, has a cubby and is seated in pods of four. Great to bounce around ideas and hear what's happening in other parts of the floor. There are usually weekly meetings and assignments are distributed on a timely basis. Most reviews here mention benefits, like organized trips and concerts, but most people on the investment team tends to be less social.

Cons

I came to the Fool under the impression that it runs like a startup, where new ideas are accepted and everyone is encouraged to participate. In reality, the Fool runs like a big company, no different than your typical Wall Street company. It's very hierarchical and you don't get much say especially if you are new. To stay afloat, you need to put your head down and do what your manager tells you to do. Be prepared to have managers way younger than you. They may not know what they talking about, investment-wise, but they'll have seniority over you, because they've been at the Fool longer. The investment team lacks diversity -- there are very few women and employees of color. Many of its new hires tends to be mainstream rejects. In other words, if you don't fit the traditional mold (college + MBA + work experience), the Fool will likely hire you. Everything at the Fool is about doing it the "Fool-ish" way and God forbid you come in to the company with previous experience, especially Wall Street experience, you'll be shunned and ostracized. The Fool prides itself as being anti-Wall Street, so definitely don't flaunt your past experiences or expertise. No matter your background, when you enter the Fool, you start from ground zero and must work your way up. Unfortunately, it's very hard, because performance isn't based on merit, but on how effective you are at sucking up to the right people. If you are new at the company, definitely don't speak up and voice your ideas, unless you want a target on your back. There is a strong sense of unspoken rule that seniority (or length of time at the Fool) dictates whether you make a good investor. Management will say that the company turnover rate is low, but the reality is they just don't count many of the folks who left within a year. For an investment analyst, the pay is very low especially compared to the market average. It's a comfortable job with great hours, but other than that, I wouldn't consider this a great investment company.

2.0
Sep 20, 2015

Not what it used to be

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The benefits and flexibility are great and lots are different than other companies. Alcohol flows freely and partying is viewed as a collaborative tool, so if you're a big drinker you will fit right in. Sometimes the great benefits are kind of a smoke and mirrors thing since the company tends to pay under market rates for many employees, but there are bonuses that can make up some of the difference.

Cons

The company was once a revolutionary, creative, and highly intellectual workplace, but most of the people who made it that way seem to have been pushed to the corner or pushed out. These days "innovation" has morphed into a “freewheeling” atmosphere that really just feels like a frat house or a high school clique. As other reviews have stated, there is a constant state of flux. But it goes way beyond making employees more innovative, and instead can be confusing to the point of paralyzing and pointless. Eventually people realize the strategy is that there is no real strategy. It’s hard to work on projects that turn out to be whims that nobody ends up caring about even though there was supposedly excitement about them from the top. Some high-profile whims become major business mistakes, a lot of them have to do with chasing short-term goals or things that have nothing to do with the core business. Too much base marketing (our customers hate it too and find it embarrassing), but that ship has sailed and the brand is in many ways tarnished beyond repair. Also, despite the “transparency” buzzword, the truth is that most people don’t know why some employees are viewed as “top performers” and promoted and others are demoted or even let go which makes people spend more time “networking” and being political with each other than being productive. Definitions of success and failure seem like who’s popular or now and has infused the office with a toxic "every man for himself" atmosphere. Speaking of men, it’s also not an easy place for females to succeed, period. There’s also a massive HR team that despite (hopefully) good intentions isn’t really effective, and other employees seem to be judged much more harshly about success or failure than that team is. There are lots of miserable people at the company right now, so things are going down a bad road.

1.0
May 26, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The Motley Fool presents a tantalizing front: they advertise themselves as a mission-driven, fun-loving workplace. New hires are typically enticed by the promises of a dynamic, progressive environment.

Cons

After a year of being with the company, one begins to see the stark differences between the glossy promises and grim reality. The main issues revolve around incompetent management, excessive favoritism, lack of career growth and direction, and stringent micromanagement. The turnover rate is high - many employees leave within their first 1-2 years, feeling disillusioned and unsatisfied. Those who do choose to stay tend to be "the favorites", who get raises even in the midst of budget cuts, take advantage of the company's five-month parental leave on top of the unlimited PTO, and keep their dissatisfaction quiet. Management positions seem to be filled from this pool of favorites. Unfortunately, these individuals lack the necessary leadership training and are incapable of leading a team or inspiring their subordinates. It's a commonly held belief that people leave bosses, not companies. In the case of The Motley Fool, it holds true. The culture of the company is rife with conflicts and issues. Even though the company encourages open communication, raising your voice against the prevailing issues appears to be career suicide. Retaliation and gaslighting are all too common here. If you dare to raise concerns against "the favorites", you may find yourself denied a raise, promotion, or even worse, faced with termination. While the Motley Fool has potential to be a great workplace, it is currently a long way from living up to its promises. Unless drastic changes are made, the company is bound to lose valuable talent and foster a toxic work environment.

Viewing 4 - 6 of 303 Reviews

Glassdoor has 433 The Motley Fool reviews submitted anonymously by The Motley Fool employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if The Motley Fool is right for you.