How does the salary as Underwriting Manager at Selective Insurance compare with the base salary range for this job?

The average salary for Underwriting Manager is $153,429 per year (estimate) in US , which is 8% higher than the average Selective Insurance salary of $141,853 per year (estimate) for this job.

Are Underwriting Manager professionals at Selective Insurance in US satisfied with their compensation?

Selective Insurance employees working as Underwriting Manager in US have attributed a compensation and benefits rating of 4 out of 5 stars, based on 3 ratings. This is 25% higher than the average of Underwriting Manager professionals at Selective Insurance worldwide.

What is the salary trajectory of a Underwriting Manager?

The salary trajectory of a Underwriting Manager ranges between locations and employers. The salary starts at $78,741 per year (estimate) and goes up to $303,102 per year (estimate) for the highest level of seniority.

How much does a Underwriting Manager make at Selective Insurance?

The estimated average salary for a Underwriting Manager at Selective Insurance is $153,429 per year or $74 per hour, but some professionals have reported earning up to roughly $254,882 per year (90th percentile). The typical pay range is between $118,708 (25th percentile) and $201,511 (75th percentile) annually. This is based on 6 salaries submitted by Selective Insurance Underwriting Manager professionals on Glassdoor, as of Jul 2026.

What is the typical salary for a Underwriting Manager per hour?

Underwriting Manager professionals typically earn between $57 and $97 per hour.

What is the typical salary for a Underwriting Manager per month?

Underwriting Manager professionals typically earn between $9,892 and $16,793 monthly.

What is the pay for job titles similar to Underwriting Manager at Selective Insurance?

Underwriter Trainee - with an estimated total pay of $61K - $88K/yr, Underwriting Specialist - with an estimated total pay of $64K - $92K/yr, Commercial Lines Underwriter - with an estimated total pay of $69K - $94K/yr, Renewal Underwriter - with an estimated total pay of $70K - $94K/yr, Personal Lines Underwriter - with an estimated total pay of $70K - $95K/yr

Skip to content Skip to footer

Notifications

Selective Insurance

All Selective Insurance salaries

Total salary range for Selective Insurance Underwriting Manager

Total Pay

$120K

$169K_/yr

About our data

Last updated Apr 10, 20256 Salaries submitted

Pay breakdown

$142K

Median total pay

Base Pay

90.6%

$110K - $150K/yr

$128K/yrmedian

Bonus

9.4%

$10K - $19K/yr

$13K/yrmedian

Deep dive into Pay

Recent salaries shared by Underwriting Manager at Selective Insurance

Job Title | Years of Experience

Base • Additional pay

Location

Date submitted

Job Title | Years of Experience

Location

Date submitted

Base • Additional pay

Underwriting Manager

15+ years

$163K/yr

($163K • $0)

Indianapolis, IN

submitted on Oct 8, 2025

$163K/yr

$163K • $0

Underwriting Manager

15+ years

$111K/yr

($100K • $11K)

Indianapolis, IN

submitted on Mar 4, 2025

$111K/yr

$100K • $11K

Anonymously share your salary to help the community.

Underwriting Manager

15+ years

$153K - $178K/yr

Branchville, NJ

submitted on Feb 21, 2024

$153K - $178K/yr

Underwriting Manager

10-14 years

$93K - $108K/yr

Indianapolis, IN

submitted on Aug 15, 2021

$93K - $108K/yr

Underwriting Manager

15+ years

$135K - $158K/yr

Branchville, NJ

submitted on Aug 4, 2021

$135K - $158K/yr

Viewing 1 - 5 of 5

Top companies for "Compensation and Benefits" near you

Liberty Mutual Insurance

3.8★Compensation & Benefits

Progressive Insurance

3.9★Compensation & Benefits

USAA

3.8★Compensation & Benefits

Travelers

4.2★Compensation & Benefits

Selective Insurance pay FAQs

Selective Insurance pay & benefits Selective Insurance salaries Selective Insurance Underwriting Manager salaries

Selective Insurance

Total salary range for Selective Insurance Underwriting Manager

About our data

Pay breakdown

$142K

Recent salaries shared by Underwriting Manager at Selective Insurance

Top companies for "Compensation and Benefits" near you

Selective Insurance pay FAQs

Want the inside scoop on your own company?

Bowls

Followed companies

Job searches

Total salary range for Selective Insurance Underwriting Manager

About our data

Pay breakdown

$142K

Top companies for "Compensation and Benefits" near you

Selective Insurance pay FAQs