AmTrust reviews

3.8

67% would recommend to a friend

(877 total reviews)

Barry D. Zyskind

75% approve of CEO

69% positive business outlook

AmTrust has an employee rating of 3.8 out of 5 stars, based on 877 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The AmTrust employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

877 reviews
1.0
May 26, 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Livable wage OK benefits Lots of holidays (changes by year, but around 14) LinkedIn Learning subscriptions Wrote code that actually went to production Some progress has been made automating builds and testing, varies by team and project Decent work-life balance (generally not expected to work over 40 hours, occasional releases around 8-9pm which can be done from home) I worked with some great people (although most of them have also left or put in notice).

Cons

Monitoring via software (Sapience) started way before the pandemic - slices time at narrow intervals and does not reflect full time worked. In Cleveland, comped parking is about a mile from the office (municipal lot off highway 2) I joined less than a year before Covid started, so most of my remaining comments reflect the company's behavior during the pandemic. The company initially seemed to be sincerely concerned with employee wellbeing when they announced everyone would switch to remote work suddenly at the end of March 2020. They then also used that as an excuse to not pay out bonuses or raises, and to not offer promotions, even though the review process was complete and changes should have been in effect within days. They did this without making an official statement - just kept not answering questions and not delivering. Over the summer there were layoffs, although the company would only refer to them as furloughs and kept insisting no one had been laid off. Those employees never got to come back, although hiring continued. In response to ongoing complaints and questions, they finally paid out bonuses in late summer. There is not official structure to how bonuses are handled, so it was just an unexplained check for whoever got them. They continued to not answer questions about raises and promotions. At a town hall (video call) in summer 2020, they presented a "staged approach" to return to office, apparently hoping to get people to return without forcing it. Having the option for people with poor working conditions at home was nice, although most people did not choose to go (in early 2021 they disclosed office attendance was around 7%). During the town hall, direct questions were asked about laid off workers returning, what was happening with raises and promotions, and what the post-Covid office policy would be - all were deflected, except for an insistence that the company would never stay fully remote (despite continually strong performance during remote work). One attendee suggested that good employees would be lost to competitors if these issues weren't answered and flexible work wasn't preserved; the CIO laughed in response as he dismissed the concern. In November, the company pivoted to discussing 2021 raises and bonuses. In early 2021 at another town hall, they disclosed that we had met all sales goals and performed well overall - backpedaling when asked questions about raises and ongoing remote work. Raises and promotions were actually handled on schedule (or close enough) in April 2021, but the vast majority of people I talked to got 1% or less after getting skipped entirely in 2020. In mid or late April 2021, they made an announcement via company-wide email that everyone would be required to return to the office full time starting June 1. The related intranet article featured several dozens of comments from employees expressing negative feedback. HR responded with canned messaging that often failed to address the concerns being brought up, and linked to external resources that contradicted the company's decision. They eventually locked the thread to prevent further comments - 100% of the comments given by non-management employees were negative. Every single positive comment was from management, leadership, or an executive assistant. Specific to software development: Pay is pretty low, and several people I talked to said meaningful raises came only from promotions or counter-offers when threatening to quit. There is very little direction or cohesion, especially across teams. Everything is the top priority, so there's no actual clear priority. Expected timelines are not reasonable, and are not adjusted based on changes - just orders to do everything now. Outsourced developers seem to be continuously brought in, while in-house staff dwindles. Several people speculated out loud that this was an intentional move by the company to stop having internal development. I don't think that's entirely the case, but it's a reasonable conclusion.

avatar
AmTrust Response
5y
We appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback and experience with us and are continuously striving to make our organization better and enhance our culture. Your insights will help us in this effort. We wish you all the best in the future.
1.0
Apr 13, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

PTO - Lots of paid holidays

Cons

Below average pay. Long hours. The company is currently outsourcing 90 percent of the IT staff. It is selling off most of the LOB's. Those who will be kept, mostly management, have little to no knowledge in managing employees or exactly what their employees actually do. The company is in turmoil. Employees if not laid off or in the process of Layoff are planning on leaving. The whole environment is toxic and smacks of failure. Raises are nonexistent unless your are are a part of the click. Bonuses are given only to the favorites. The future outlook is extremely poor. Run away!

avatar
AmTrust Response
7y
Thank you for your feedback. Please be assured that you can discuss any issues, concerns, or career challenges you are experiencing with our HR team in complete confidence. To reach out, please contact AmTrustCareers@amtrustgroup.com or meet directly with your regional HR representative.
2.0
Feb 21, 2019

Think long and hard

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good vacation, casual dress code, flex-time with work from home days and limited supervision.

Cons

No growth potential for female employees. Upper management has a mold for what a leader looks like to them and unfortunately that mold does not include being female or a minority. There is a cultural of favoritism that runs rampant and has caused them to lose many young talented individuals to competitors. Management also makes promises they never intend to keep. They really try to get you in the door only to squander your full potential.

avatar
AmTrust Response
7y
Thank you for your feedback. We utilize Glassdoor to better understand our employee’s experience so that we can continue to be a strong employer. Thank you again and we wish you all the best in your future.
Viewing 7 - 9 of 877 Reviews

Glassdoor has 1,435 AmTrust reviews submitted anonymously by AmTrust employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if AmTrust is right for you.