Goodwill reviews

3.2

46% would recommend to a friend

(9,236 total reviews)

Catherine Meloy

50% approve of CEO

39% positive business outlook

Goodwill has an employee rating of 3.2 out of 5 stars, based on 9,236 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Goodwill employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Nonprofit & NGO industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

9K reviews
1.0
Apr 13, 2011
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great employees with strong work ethic in the store. Decent pay and benefits for not requiring a college degree. Sometimes fun to work in the production area, and on a store-by-store basis supervisors can have freedom to work on their own projects (I say that with reservation...check out the store you're applying for first!) Workshops and other escapes from the daily grind were also pretty fun.

Cons

The company seems to promote mediocrity and punish those who try to make things better. I saw way too many incompetent managers last months, even years, while countless individuals who made small mistakes were immediately terminated. Employees were afraid to speak their minds (even when they would offer helpful suggestions) for fear of punishment. Store manager ruled the place with an iron fist with some of the most unintentionally hilarious rules, all of which held the manager to a different standard than all other employees at the store. Supervisors were regularly held to the same production standards as line employees and were written up if they did not match the full-time production workers' standards (even when they spent the entire day busy with supervisory work). At the same time, when employees at my store attempted to reach out to upper-level management, they were continually ignored. Most of the "troublemakers" who found the store manager's rules to be unfair were fired before they could get their cases heard at HR. It's a huge gamble where you get hired on as to what your working conditions will be like. Many of the store managers (and a few Regional Directors) are great and will gladly listen to employees' concerns, but one never really knows until they get hired, where they're going to be. Many good managers at the company are weighed down by the incompetent people above them. If you're looking for a guaranteed good experience in management, you'll want to do more research before you apply here.

1.0
Oct 12, 2025

Greedwill not GOODwill

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Full time work certainly available

Cons

Good was never good enough, meeting outrageous quota expectancies was put on loyal workers that showed up for work, while the slackers got their butts kissed. When you have a bully employee that runs the store and everyone including management bows to for the fear of being reported to HR, or even higher up. The actions of employees that are held to accountability destroys moral of hard working employees. Then to have a head supervisor that doesn't help out physically when short handed , and pulls the rank card due to his tenor w company. He's a joke. Athens on eastside is horribly run, and is not kept up.

1.0
Apr 12, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

You’ll get actual full time hours.

Cons

I’ve worked here almost a year. - horrible management - HR is the laziest and most unhelpful department that I have ever seen. - If you make a formal complaint, it will not be kept anonymous, and you will likely face backlash. - Lack of proper conditions (extreme heat, extreme cold, black mold growing in the ceilings, wasp nests forming, occasionally no space to work, etc.), - Not enough pay for the work/stress you are expected to put up with - Have to make up other peoples’ slack - Have to put up with poor body odor from coworkers - They say there’s room for career advancement, but there’s not. If you want to advance, you have to memorize many numbers, policies, and even the kinds of labels you have to use for boxes. Meanwhile, they’ll hire in anyone off the street even if they don’t have experience for the position. - Have to deal with people who absolutely do not care how you feel about any of the above. - Customers are the most entitled people ever. They will call you names, literally scratch you trying to grab things off of carts/racks, and parents will let their kids mess up entire aisles and not pick it up.

Viewing 97 - 99 of 9,236 Reviews

Glassdoor has 9,738 Goodwill reviews submitted anonymously by Goodwill employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Goodwill is right for you.