New Home Star reviews

4.2

75% would recommend to a friend

(369 total reviews)
avatar

David Rice

84% approve of CEO

81% positive business outlook

New Home Star has an employee rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars, based on 369 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an excellent working experience there. The New Home Star employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Real Estate industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

369 reviews
1.0
Jun 25, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

1.) Some genuinely good people doing their best in a broken system. 2.) A great place to learn sales, marketing, and real estate, fast. You’ll get experience that most people wait years for. 3.) All-expenses-paid trips, frequent training sessions, and team bonding events make it a solid environment for single reps or relocates looking to build connections. Some of the best memories and learning moments! 4.) Opportunities to learn resilience, self-motivation, and how to advocate for yourself. You’ll come out stronger, whether by choice or necessity. 5.) Creative in house developed tools, the kind that usually cost thousands, are provided to you for free (though their impact is limited without proper traffic). 6.) You’ll make friends quickly, partly because the social events feel mandatory, even if technically “optional.” **If you’re married or have kids, expect some friction around that. 7.) At its best, the culture feels exciting and full of potential. You really can grow here; if the conditions allow it. Get harassed, bullied and HR and owners don’t help, it’s a dog eat dog place and favoritism is king.

Cons

1.) Culture is performative, not lived. The company presents an image of care, empowerment, and unity—but behind the scenes, silence is safer than honesty. If you need an advocate, you won’t find one. Harassment is tolerated when it comes from a favorite. 2.) Feedback is not welcome unless it flatters. Constructive ideas—even when shared professionally—can mark you as a “problem.” I repeatedly asked for the company website to be updated. It still says things like “Located just 4 miles from downtown Springboro” (it’s 1.4), or references to “the Gardens at Historic Springboro Mansion” (that’s a private home). It lists homes as “up to 2,800 square feet,” when the largest is over 3,700. These inaccuracies caused buyer distrust and lost sales. I spoke up, and I was mocked for my body—then fired. 3.) Leadership no longer promotes from within. The culture shifted from the “NHS Way of Leading” to something more traditional, impersonal, and driven by metrics over people—wrapped in a forced smile. 4.) Work-life balance is unsustainable. Events may be called “optional,” but if you miss them, it’s noticed. Even your one day off isn’t truly yours if you want to be seen as a team player. This is especially hard on those with families. 5.) The tools are great—but useless without traffic. You’re expected to bring in leads with a $300 co-op marketing budget split between two people—and often that budget isn’t even approved for its intended use. So you end up spending your own money, waiting on changes leadership refuses to make. 6.) Burnout is common. Instead of addressing root causes, leadership stays focused on optics and performance theater. There’s little acknowledgment of the human cost. 7.) Accountability is inconsistent. Some employees get write-ups and still get promoted. Others are given inaccurate data, denied time to respond, and terminated before the review period ends. Leadership missteps are rarely addressed. 8.) You will feel disposable. Even high performers are let go if they no longer fit the narrative. I had a 16–20% conversion rate, zero cancels in two years, and I was terminated after pointing out what was stalling traffic. Culture, right?

1.0
Jan 9, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Working here is an experience that can only be described as a blend of smoke and mirrors, wrapped in a cult-like environment. The training provided was essentially a rehash of outdated practices borrowed from a national builder, reflecting a striking disconnect from the current needs of today’s buyers and builders. It was apparent that many in upper management were more followers than leaders, often trying to compensate for insecurities rooted in their pasts. The owner’s ego-driven approach was particularly challenging. He frequently referenced his personal struggles, which seemed to serve as a way to establish a false sense of superiority among the team. While there is some merit to the training offered for newcomers in sales, it quickly becomes evident that staying beyond a year or two could severely limit your opportunities with more reputable national builders. Most in the industry have never even heard of [Past Employer Name], which can be a significant drawback for career advancement. If you're considering a position here, I strongly advise you to think twice. Starting as an assistant at a reputable national builder would provide a much more solid foundation for your career. The company tends to hire young and inexperienced individuals, likely because they are easier to influence and mold into the company culture. It’s a path that may lead to disillusionment rather than growth. Save yourself the trouble and seek opportunities that will genuinely advance your career.

Cons

Read review and judge for yourself.

2.0
Nov 3, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Fun personalities and good training.

Cons

The commission structure offered at New Home Star is the worst I’ve seen in the real estate industry. They do offer a small salary to accompany the commissions but don’t expect annual raises, or any other raises.

Viewing 43 - 45 of 369 Reviews

Glassdoor has 397 New Home Star reviews submitted anonymously by New Home Star employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if New Home Star is right for you.