Pie Insurance reviews

3.2

47% would recommend to a friend

(161 total reviews)
avatar

John Swigart

59% approve of CEO

38% positive business outlook

Pie Insurance has an employee rating of 3.2 out of 5 stars, based on 161 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Pie Insurance employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

161 reviews
3.0
Mar 14, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I met some amazing and talented people. I was able to jump into projects that furthered my career growth. Solid benefits.

Cons

Pay was below average and did not keep up with extra responsibilities or job scope expansion, at least for me. Politics everywhere. Not sure how they decide to spend their money; 2 layoffs in 2 years but they continue to hire and have executives travel around the country. I had 4 managers in 2 years. They cut bonuses and capped raises. I saw some HR folks getting promotions mid year while the rest of the company has to wait for review season.

avatar
Pie Insurance Response
2y
Thank you for sharing thoughts about your time at Pie Insurance. We're glad to hear you had positive experiences and were able to grow your career with us. We appreciate your feedback and want to clarify points you made regarding bonuses, raises and promotions. Ensuring fair compensation and transparent decision-making are top priorities for us. Every year, our People Team does an extensive market review to ensure our compensation remains competitive within the market. Bonuses are paid to those who are eligible every year based on board approvals, company performance and team member performance. In terms of promotions, throughout the year, we do off-cycle promotions which resulted in over 80 promotions across the organization in 2023.
2.0
Mar 25, 2025

So much potential

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Fully remote, unlimited PTO, great healthcare plan, the attempts at transparency are appreciated, some great co-workers and middle management.

Cons

Job security is nonexistent. Small layoffs are occurring almost monthly that don't take into account how critical the roles may be. I've seen positions eliminated that were shocking. The disconnect in upper management is staggering at times. The push to become profitable is so strong it feels dire even though we've been told it isn't. Co-founder is leaving the company. You typically don't jump ship when things are going great. Pie has a major culture issue at the moment and there appears to be zero attempt at solving it. The highest C-suite turnover I've ever seen in my career. Since I've joined Pie the CFO, CTO, CAO, Chief Claims Officer, Chief legal officer, and Chief Commercial Officer have all left the company either on their own or through reorgs. I'd be willing to bet Pie gets acquired/sold within 12 months.

1.0
Jan 16, 2025

Outlook is not great

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Pay, work from home, unlimited PTO

Cons

The company has no direction. They are spinning with the hope that Comm Auto is going to be the savior, yet can't figure out how to operate basic work comp. The infrastructure is broken even after a RIF where the revenue team was almost completely dissolved. They have teams with more leadership roles than IC's. I was lucky and left on my own, but in my opinion as a former employee, this is not a company anyone should be running to work for. They also preach how it's a great culture and will post "best places to work" awards, but that is not reality. There is a deep division between departments and little to no collaboration between teams.

Viewing 16 - 18 of 161 Reviews

Glassdoor has 164 Pie Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by Pie Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Pie Insurance is right for you.