employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

NCSA College Recruiting

Engaged Employer

NCSA College Recruiting reviews

3.0

46% would recommend to a friend

(776 total reviews)

Brent Richard

58% approve of CEO

46% positive business outlook

NCSA College Recruiting has an employee rating of 3.0 out of 5 stars, based on 776 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The NCSA College Recruiting employee rating is 22% below average for employers within the Arts, Entertainment & Recreation industry (3.9 stars).

Reviews by job title

776 reviews
2.0
Feb 26, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Most of the staff at NCSA is awesome, solid people all around. I genuinely enjoyed just about everyone I worked with. Lots of fun social events, including the Turkey Bowl. - Lots of opportunities to help families in the recruiting process whether they ultimately decide to enroll or not. I truly enjoyed many of the conversations I had with families and genuinely felt I was making a difference at times. - The services and products NCSA provides are solid, despite the sticker shock, for student-athletes and families needing help in the recruiting process IF they are willing to put the work into using them. - The interview process when I was first hired was efficient, I had an offer the day after my final interview. - Causal Dress

Cons

- Despite some positives, the recruiting coordinator position can be rough for many reasons. The job itself is very boring. It is basically just one giant call center. You make 50-100 calls per day on a “smile and dial” mindset. Literally, your job is to set sales meetings for families with closers and that is it. I hardly found the job challenging due to its repetitive nature. - The work-life balance can be frustrating in the position. There is a lot of pressure to work evenings and weekends. The company constantly preaches that it is trying to improve work-life balance for employees but never actually makes any meaningful improvements. - The micromanagement in this position can be way too much at times. Some managers will get on to you too much about certain metrics. There is a tremendous pressure to set a certain number of meetings per day, even if they are not quality sets. - The leads I got almost every day when I first started were terrible. The position is cold calling families roughly 75% of the time. Many of the lead sources are very frustrating as well. Sometimes you feel like you are annoying families in trying to get in touch with them more so than actually helping them. Much of the time, because of these bad lead sources, you are calling families that didn’t realize they sent their info to NCSA and then get mad when you reach out. - The base pay for the position is terrible. It is currently $30k, which is actually up from $27k when I first took the job. Although under the current structure you are not eligible to earn commission until you have at least 50 enrollments, which means even if you find success right away you are just stuck with the base pay plus overtime for your first few months. - It is possible to make decent money in this position, but you will have to be prepared to consistently work 55+ hours and 6+ days a week. In my last month at NCSA I was right around the company average in enrollments, in addition to working roughly 45-50 hours a week, and still easily made less than $40k/annualized for the month for the amount of work I was putting in, and I know I was not alone. - I felt I was misled on how realistic/easy it was to earn a decent commission in the interview process. Additionally, the commission you earn is based on the sales your Recruiting Specialists make from the meetings you set with them. Thus, you do not have absolute control over the commission you make. - The burnout and turnover rate in this position is very high. Personally, I already felt burnt out after about 2 months and left for a new job after 5. Very few people last over a year in this role. NCSA struggles to even retain some of its top performers in the role. I would say about half of my recruitment team is planning on leaving within the next couple of months or is actively looking for a new job. - There is very little room to grow up in the company from the RC role, despite what management says. Management positions are few and far between. You have to complete a career development program to move up in the company in any capacity. - Some other reviews on Glassdoor argue that NCSA is all about profit and does not actually care about the families. I absolutely disagree with this based on my experience especially since there are some tremendous people at NCSA, BUT there is an absolute pressure to set and enroll a high volume of families. As a result, recruiting coordinators and specialists are often pressured to qualify, set, and enroll unqualified student-athletes. A solid number of student-athletes in NCSA’s network will never see the field/court in college. - The company is currently hiring way too fast in sales, while on the flipside, the company is completely understaffed on the service side. I had multiple families contact me after enrolling as they were struggling to get in touch with their recruiting coach after spending thousands of dollars on our service side. - NCSA is never afraid to pat itself on the back and the rah-rah culture can be very annoying. - There were issues of RCs stealing top recruits/leads from other RCs and management hardly did anything about it. - Leaving NCSA was a mess. While it didn't happen to me, it is a common procedure for managers to fire RCs on the spot at NCSA when they give a two-week notice.

avatar
NCSA College Recruiting Response
7y
Thank you for your feedback on the Recruiting Coordinator role. I agree with you about our team – we have some amazing people who work at NCSA and they’re all very passionate about helping families, as I can tell you were as well. We make it very clear throughout the interview process that this is an entry level role where you will be dialing the phone 50-100 per day while also giving an extensive overview of the compensation plan that we offer. When conducting interviews in our Chicago and Las Vegas office, we have candidates sit and shadow current coordinators to observe the day to day of the role. Ultimately, we prioritize making sure that this role is the right fit for the candidate upon acceptance and that this type of work that falls in line with current career goals. We often will see that candidates with prior experience will transition to the entry-level recruiting coordinator role in search of a path in the sports industry and an opportunity to work in a field they are passionate about. Due to this being a role where we are looking to connect with parents of student-athletes, weekend hours or some additional time in the evening, where overtime is earned, can be mutually beneficial for our coordinators and families to speak when more time allows. Families that we are reaching out to can range as to where they currently stand in the recruiting process. A reason why the role does entail making a high volume of calls daily rests on the fact that there has been an influx of families showing interest in the potential of their son or daughter continuing to play their sport at the college level. Whether or not the family knows of NCSA and what we do as an organization, the role of the recruiting coordinator is to educate families on a process that most are engaging for the first time. Being a goal-oriented company, we often like to hear from our coordinators about what goals they are looking to accomplish on a monthly basis. That way, from a management perspective, we can work together on developing a plan as to what needs to take place on a daily basis to achieve those goals. We will communicate daily on different metrics and coaching points that will allow you to reach your full potential in the role-based heavily on what the coordinator is looking to achieve professionally. Our career development program has served as a great opportunity for our top performing recruiting coordinators to grow their skill, become more knowledgeable in business acumen, and has been reliable in identifying the right individuals to either move into a management role (have hired 7 managers in the last 18 months) or also explore other opportunities within NCSA. For those that have completed the CDP program and have explored opportunities both in and outside NCSA, it represents growth, development, continual learning, and commitment which has led to many having success in taking that next step in their careers. With any company, it does take time to grow and to grow we must be able to see you having success in your current day to day which is what the CDP program signifies. Finally, our goal at NCSA is to offer world-class service to families and help student-athletes find the right college fit. As a rapidly growing company, we are hiring a high number of new teammates. We currently have more families reaching out to NCSA than ever before, so we need to hire many Recruiting Coordinators to be able to connect with those families. Thanks again for your feedback. We wish you the best of luck with your career journey.
1.0
Jul 28, 2017
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good mission in theory, and it can help kids, but promises made to way too kids that they can play at the next level just so they pay the fee to join our network.

Cons

Everything else. 75% of the 100+ guys and gals in my department (recruiting specialists) from when I started are now gone. They don't care about work/life balance, working 7 days a week. Best leads are given to the "favorites"....which is the 25% of department that still remains

avatar
NCSA College Recruiting Response
7y
Thanks for taking the time to write a review. It’s now a year later as I read your review again and write this response, and I’m still saddened to see your comments. Our mission here at NCSA is to change lives through sports. And every student-athlete who is both academically and athletically qualified to participate in collegiate athletics should have the chance to do so. That is why we help kids through a mission of providing recruiting education, assistance and connection to college coaches. Our team members are passionate about this mission and know that our tools and resources can help families. I think that’s why we win multiple company awards every year (with that passion, and our fun culture!). I know a lot has changed in the last year since you’ve been a part of our sales team, so I believe if you were still with us you’d have some new insight to share here. And if you read this response, I hope you’ve found a home at your new job. Good luck to you!
5.0
Mar 21, 2017

Helping student-athletes go to college

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

It's amazing to work for a company that cares about helping athletes get college degrees. NCSA is offers a fast-paced work environment with big ideas and a commitment to reward success and give back to the community.

Cons

To achieve success here, you'll need to be a self-starter. Most positions require solid to advanced technical/computer skills.

avatar
NCSA College Recruiting Response
9y
Thanks for your review! How amazing is it that we get the opportunity to say we change lives on a daily basis as our career! I’m glad to hear you’re enjoying your time at NCSA, and we hope you continue to help student-athletes achieve their dreams.
Viewing 10 - 12 of 776 Reviews

Glassdoor has 799 NCSA College Recruiting reviews submitted anonymously by NCSA College Recruiting employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if NCSA College Recruiting is right for you.