employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Renewal by Andersen

Part of Andersen

Engaged Employer

Renewal by Andersen reviews

3.6

60% would recommend to a friend

(2,319 total reviews)
avatar

Troy Barrow

74% approve of CEO

58% positive business outlook

Renewal by Andersen has an employee rating of 3.6 out of 5 stars, based on 2,319 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Renewal by Andersen employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Manufacturing industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

2K reviews
1.0
Apr 17, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

If you have the financial means to support your household during the first 4-6 months of your employment without seeing significant income from Renewal by Andersen, and you are out of better options; a sales position here may just be the last resort "lifeline" you need to get you by during hard times, until you are able to obtain a more worthy sales position with a real company. If you can avoid taking this option altogether, you'll be better off. The sales really slow down in the winter months here, so hopefully you plan ahead financially for those months as well. Usually right before Thanksgiving, through Christmas and New Years and February they don't have much marketing budget. You should expect to spend a majority of your time meeting with "inquiries" which are essentially colder leads that have a slimmer chance of closing on the same day. If you plan to follow up or have a pipline, they don't allow it. They rehash the leads and when/if an inquiry reaches out to place their order, a secondary consultant is sent to take the order. This strange approach to customer relationships could be a hint as to why they have a 2.4 star yelp rating. I have never experienced this type of practice in any sales job I've had prior. Read below for some other hints about this company and how they approach their internal customers (the employees) there are many deeply concerning issues.

Cons

A majority of the sales representative reviews for this company are posted in waves (often all on the same day) by consultants who have been employed for under 1 year. These reviews are often mysteriously void of ANY "cons" and offer minimal insight otherwise. The reason for this is due to the reviews being coerced by sales managers to essentially force sales consultants who are at the end of their run with Renewal by Andersen (typically this stage is reached after about 9-10 months). They are asked to show they are a good "team player" and to "help the company" or something along those lines. Why they do it is rooted in a false hope that their loyalty will buy them time on the chopping block. Unfortunately, most will be chopped anyway and that's why they were asked to do a bogus review in the first place. Renewal by Andersen is a company with the mentality that you hire 5 to keep 1. So they want to make sure they get 3 or 4 "great reviews" right before the revolving door spins. They are very good at this tactic and it's unfortunate they feel the need to resort to it. Luckily I was never chopped, so my review is honest and not coerced. I came to Renewal with 27+ years of sales experience spanning multiple industries. I have been a top performer for every organization I've sold or managed for, including Renewal by Andersen and their illustrious "president's club". The presidents club is only achieved by a select few salespeople and is based on various performance metrics including but not limited to, close rate and net sales. I achieved this distinction within my first 9 months of selling at Renewal. I am a woman with no construction background who has never sold home improvement projects before and if it weren't for my extensive experience in sales prior to Renewal by Andersen, I do not believe i would have had much success. My managers had very little construction knowledge and could rarely assist me with questions. They also lacked sales aptitude, leadership and motivational skills to put it mildly. I was once given a sales award trophy by my manager and no sooner than the award being placed in my hands, issued a "verbal warning" for being 8 minutes late to the sales meeting. I had an emergency with one of my children and notified my manager prior to the meeting beginning. This is just one example of which I have MANY. Including being reprimand over the phone by my manager for selling a cash deal instead of financing it. Imagine that? Hard to believe but yes, I was scolded for SELLING. Only at RBA! Got to love it. The leadership team at this company is undoubtedly the least professional I've ever come accross in my entire sales career. Starting with the president and running down the ladder to the sales managers, there is a clear lack of experience and leadership ability which has lended itself to the lowest moral sales team I've ever been a part of. Granted, I decided this type of leadership group wouldn't be advantageous to my career and I resigned from the sales position after about a year to pursue a far better opportunity at the advice of several trusted people within my network; including the first manager I ever worked for when I was 18 years old and starting in sales. Yes we stay in touch! I have always been surrounded by true proffesionals until venturing into Renewal by Andersen. It's unfortunate that such people have spoiled such a unique sales opportunity for so many. Another fairly recent 1 star review touches on several other critical key points regarding the toxic culture, and is worth reading if you're still considering working here. When I was selling for Renewal, the compensation was equal to 10% of the contract valuation, but it's since been reduced to 8% due to the leadership apparently being unaware that the company needed to pay it's sales reps the IRS rate for their mileage. It remains unclear as to why the compensation percentage was reduced simply to introduce mileage pay. Again, RED FLAGS! Leadership is not transparent or competient. The current IRS mileage rate of 67 cents per mile but they cut pay from 10% to 8% to cover it and told everyone its better for them. Do the math and see if it's better. Let's say you drive 112 miles from your home to an appointment in the morning rush hour traffic to get to your first appointment of the day. You won't get the 67 cents per mile for this 112 mile drive (per the agreement). Let's say they then send you 5 miles away to your next appointment before you drive back home for the day. This means you will be able to claim only the 5 mile drive from your morning appointment to your second appointment of the day. That's $3.35. It doesn't take much math skills to see that getting 67 cents per mile for portions of your commutes will never annually equate to 2% of say $250,000. Do your homework on this place and don't believe the fake reviews. They will take advantage of you if you let them. All of their top performing sales reps absorbed a monster pay cut due to the pay reduction and many of them will probably seek new and more lucrative sales positions elsewhere. It's not uncommon to receive 10% (or more) commission as well as mileage reimbursement in the home improvement sales space. Renewal by Andersen will struggle to reach new heights due to their inability and unwillingness to attract and retain talented professionals.

1.0
Jul 28, 2016
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

(Reiteration, this is for private branches not the corporate branch) - Relatively care-free mood - They equip you with necessary training (most of the time) - Company parties in the winter - Cash bonuses and incentives to do better - Weekly paychecks (bi-weekly for managers) - Traveling across the state and seeing new places - State managers are usually very helpful

Cons

(Reiteration, this is for private branches not the corporate branch) - They cut corners, and the corners that get cut are people's livelihood - Company emphasis, being on money, foregoes logistics and many other important factors that keep employees happy - Care-free attitude turns into job endangerment very quickly - Middle Management sucks (regional managers) - The company is bad about providing real solutions to real problems and, instead, goes with the fake "sales plastic" ie: grin and bear it - Company recycles people, from canvassers to managers - Job is a revolving door so chances are whoever you know won't be there 6 months later - Lack of employee trust. They'll nanny you with GPS trackers, even going as far as requiring pictures to be taken of the crew before and after shift - The private franchisee owners are making money hand over fist, well into the multi-millions per year, while they cut the pay of canvassers and staffers - The company doesn't investigate problems. Instead, they drop the hammer and aggressive scold and/or fire a person without asking them what happened - Company is unwise with business model and opts to do as much production (appointments) as possible without regard for the limited territory. New houses take a minimum of 10 years before they can be touched, meaning that over the course of a year the limited territories available in some areas can get over saturated - Competitors offer windows are much, much lower in price (RbA windows start at $1200 a piece for standard, $2000 for really customized) - The only thing RbA excels at is window material. FiberEx is a great material but, for the same cost, you could buy three vinyl windows with the same level of protection and even with a minuscule 10 year warranty on them, still get 10 years longer than the RbA standard 20 year warranty, while saving money on the cost. - RbA wants to be seen as a prestigious company yet they don't give the tools required to look good or sound good. They give you boring, uninteresting videos to watch that hardly anyone actually use, old torn up binders, their paper work is all copies of copies of copies so they're blurry and look like trash, they don't even provide convenient pens so you have to basically have all your own supplies, and they regularly ask you to use your phone which can run into data/minutes problems for some people - Office managers are expected to do all office duties plus be top canvassers in their vehicles, creating a lot of stress

5.0
Aug 26, 2015
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The best place I have ever worked. Great team! Great leadership! Given the freedom to manage my time and department to results. Awesome communication between Operations and Marketing to drive to one goal. HR department is an asset and a great resource. The network of corporate owned and independent markets gives Renewal the advantage over its competitors and selling the best product on the market always gives us the advantage. The last thing I want to add is that the president of the company almost everyday has lunch in the cafeteria with the employees. He sits with different people everyday and really gets into the different parts of the business. I will never forget the time soon after I started he sat down at the table I was eating lunch at and started talking about my business area with me. Paul (the president of Renewal) is a super approachable leader and representative of the leadership team at Renewal.

Cons

We drive towards personal accountability more than any other company I have worked for. The spotlight can be hot when its on you and finger pointing is not part of the culture so you must know your numbers and your business and be able to speak to them. We are a team that sinks or swims together. This environment is not for everybody.

avatar
Renewal by Andersen Response
10y
Thanks for the review! It's great to get feedback from the team!
Viewing 4 - 6 of 2,319 Reviews

Glassdoor has 2,377 Renewal by Andersen reviews submitted anonymously by Renewal by Andersen employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Renewal by Andersen is right for you.