employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Selective Insurance

Engaged Employer

Selective Insurance reviews

2.7

32% would recommend to a friend

(126 total reviews)
avatar

John Marchioni

40% approve of CEO

37% positive business outlook

Reviews by job title

126 reviews

Reviews about "Management"

Return to all reviews
1.0
Mar 20, 2026

Overworked and Under-Supported, Despite Ambition

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Talented and collaborative co-workers who make the day-to-day work enjoyable. Hybrid schedule provides flexibility and some work-life balance. Leadership shows ambition and willingness to try new initiatives and programs. Town halls with the CEO provide transparency and the opportunity to ask questions directly.

Cons

Morale is declining rapidly, driven by leadership instability and lack of support. Managers are stepping down at an alarming rate, and many employees are avoiding leadership roles altogether. The company frequently rolls out multiple initiatives without clear direction, adequate resources, or realistic expectations. Regional teams are especially impacted, expected to absorb this work without sufficient support, which leads to burnout. There are not enough underwriting or operational roles within the regions to sustain these initiatives. Operational infrastructure is a major gap. Many regions lack dedicated support functions such as marketing, events, product, HR, IT, and design teams - forcing employees to take on significant responsibilities outside their roles without additional compensation or recognition. Career advancement opportunities in these spaces are limited, and high performers are often left in stagnant, thankless roles. Rather than developing talent, employees are often assigned expanded responsibilities beyond a sustainable capacity. Overall career development is lacking. Top performers frequently leave for higher-paying opportunities elsewhere with less stress. Processes are inefficient, and talent is often constrained by nonfunctional systems. HR is a consistent pain point. Confidentiality is a concern, support is limited, and there is a disconnect in understanding employee roles. HR often functions as a pass-through for leadership rather than a true advocate, with little innovation or modern approaches to employee development and retention. Work-life balance is poor across the organization. Expectations—especially in underwriting—are unrealistic and exhausting. Flexibility is often denied, even for reasonable schedule adjustments, despite messaging promoting a flexible culture. Upper leadership does not appear to understand the realities of working parents or the demands employees face on a daily basis with territory sizes. Processes and communication are inefficient. Vendor and contract approvals can take months, IT issues persist, and priorities frequently shift without clear communication. Goals are often unattainable, and corporate initiatives frequently overwhelm teams without proper alignment or follow-through. Many leaders feel they are simply “checking a box” for upper leadership, and frustrations are openly discussed among teams. Managers are paralyzed once in their position and have no desire to develop themselves, creating barriers for those who do - We’re losing young talent because of it. Policies are applied inconsistently. The emphasis on badge swipes and in-office tracking feels out of touch, particularly when field roles are not held to the same standards and performance or travel is ignored. While there is a sense of job security, it is overshadowed by poor communication, lack of direction, weak infrastructure, siloed leadership, a costly new corporate office location, and increasing frustration across teams.

2.0
Dec 21, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good people for the most part; career stability if you don't mind staying where you are at.

Cons

Worklife balance is nonexistent if you want to stay on top of your book. the amount of work that gets delegated to an underwriter in this company hampers the actual underwriting. You are expected to handle audit problems and billing issues and claims problems. This industry is very dependent on relationships, that being said you are expected to bow to every agent request and this really interferes with effective underwriting. Management is too cozy with Agency leaders and this bias effects the underwriting. Career progression is slow unless you know the right people.

1.0
Nov 24, 2025

Toxic working conditions

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

GREAT co-workers! Remote & semi remote jobs available.

Cons

Toxic inexperienced management with too much turnover. No one really knows what direction the company is actually going. Very limited authority allowed in underwriting. Micro management. Many inexperienced employees. DEI is top priority and drives all hiring decisions.

Viewing 13 - 15 of 126 Reviews

Glassdoor has 495 Selective Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by Selective Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Selective Insurance is right for you.