Carnegie Dartlet reviews

1.9

9% would recommend to a friend

(100 total reviews)

Gary Colen

13% approve of CEO

20% positive business outlook

Carnegie Dartlet has an employee rating of 1.9 out of 5 stars, based on 100 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a poor working experience there. The Carnegie Dartlet employee rating is 49% below average for employers within the Media & Communication industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

100 reviews
1.0
Dec 18, 2024

Disorganized and Lacking Leadership

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

All remote and great benefits.

Cons

My experience with this company was disappointing due to a lack of clear leadership and direction. Leadership was often absent, and when present, interactions felt impersonal and superficial. The company relied heavily on time tracking, which could have been automated to save time. There appeared to be an overabundance of management roles with unclear responsibilities and little opportunity for individual growth or advancement. Workflow tools were poorly implemented, leading to confusion and inefficiency. Projects frequently lacked proper communication and guidance, creating a frustrating work environment where employees were left to navigate unclear expectations. The workload often felt more like assembly-line production than creative problem-solving, which was disheartening for a creative professional who cares about the work. While the company promoted a work-life balance, the heavy emphasis on time tracking and administrative tasks created a disconnect between their stated values and actual practices. This left me feeling overworked and undervalued. I would recommend potential applicants consider these factors before applying, particularly if they value strong leadership, clear communication, and a supportive work environment.

avatar
Carnegie Dartlet Response
1y
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We’re glad you appreciated the remote flexibility and benefits, but we’re sorry to hear that other aspects of your time with Carnegie were not as positive. Leadership and clear communication are crucial, and we are actively working on improving transparency, project management, and workflow efficiencies. We also recognize the importance of fostering an environment where employees feel valued, heard, and supported in their growth. Feedback like yours is invaluable in helping Carnegie refine processes and leadership approach. If you have any further insights, please contact me at hr@carnegiehighered.com
2.0
Mar 2, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Most of the people were very friendly and open to answer any questions I had.

Cons

Interview Interview process was pretty extensive for an entry level role. Three rounds plus a 3 hour shadow session (unpaid). Shadow sessions was not helpful as I didn't have enough context to decide whether or not the role would be a good fit. Training Training was awful, to say the least. It was about 5-6 weeks jammed packed with between 6-8 training meetings per day...all about different subjects that weren't completely relevant to my role. Very hard to retain info that way. Also, be prepared introduce yourself at EVERY SINGLE MEETing. There was also very little hands on application during training, so I completed it feeling less than confident. Autonomy Even though you're salaried, you'll have to clock your time every day. Not just in and out, but you'll have to clock all of your activities you did for the day and how long it took you. They expect it to equate to 40 hours. If it doesn't, they will add more projects until it does. They say it's to monitor bandwidth, which is very odd as bandwidth varies from person to person. Very little flexibility in your day-to- day schedule, so beware parents! It's not the remote life you dream of. Need to run to kids school really quickly or have an emergency? You'll feel the judgement of it. Someone scheduled a 1:1 meeting with me. I proposed a new time for the same day because of a very personal matter, and that person (mgr) wanted to know the specific reason I needed to reschedule. Diversity + Culture Very little diversity, and cliquey culture. The 2 months I was there, no one really cared to get to know me as a person beyond initial intros. Final straw was being questioned about a meeting I missed while being out sick. They forgot I was out sick, and couldn't own up to that. Micromanagement is a form of bullying.

avatar
Carnegie Dartlet Response
3y
Thank you for your review of Carnegie, and I am sorry your experience was not positive. Carnegie has made important strides to be a family friendly company. Because we understand the importance of work/life balance we have added a generous parental leave policy, unlimited PTO, remote work, and flexibility. We require employees to clock their time as a means of project costing and we do expect someone who is scheduled to work 40 hours to work their schedule, but offering flexibility if needed. Carnegie would never tell an employee they could not take time off to take care of personal business. Your manager tried reaching out to you to discuss your concerns, but you had already resigned without notice. If you would like to discuss further, please contact me at hr@carnegiedartlet.com
2.0
Aug 8, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

With all of the acquisitions, Carnegie is truly a powerhouse of knowledge in the industry. If you can network and communicate with folks outside of your department, you're bound to have some really great conversations.

Cons

My experience may be a little unique as I came in from one of the companies that Carnegie acquired. I really, really loved the company I originally worked for, but I left soon after the merge was "final". I was not drinking the Carnegie Coolaid. Originally, we were excited about the prospect of joining the Carnegie team, but were upset about how hush-hush the whole acquisition was. It also felt like there weren't a lot of answers to our questions and concerns about the acquisition and what that meant for us. They kept saying we'd figure it out when it was finalized. However, it was clear once the acquisition was final that Carnegie had no idea what they were doing or what to do with us. Our now department acted like our own company still, just called ourselves Carnegie now, but simultaneously a lot of folks were pulled randomly into the greater Carnegie group and removed from our team. Some of the higher ups were generally involved in group slack channels and events, but their interactions felt super cliquey and exclusive; like there was always an inside joke I wasn't a part of. The Wednesday all staff meetings are so cringe and honestly completely unnecessary - it could all be accomplished with an email and I get that they want everyone to be together, but what togetherness can you get with 250+ people on a zoom call where only 5 people generally talk anyways? An other example of the disjointed and exclusivity of groups is how some groups would plan and go on these retreats or have group events and then post about how amazing they were on the general slack channel which just made everyone else feel like they were missing out or didn't deserve the same. Overall, I never felt like I was truly a part of the Carnegie Group. Upon leaving I filled out my exit interview form super honestly with constructive comments and concerns and I inquired about what happens to the form and HR informed me that only she and the COO read it and the COO would "consider the information". AKA they don't care and nothing will come of it. Since I left they've restructured my department twice and 3 more employees have left including an AVP who had been at our company (before acquisition) for 22 years.

avatar
Carnegie Dartlet Response
3y
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with Carnegie. We are not happy that your experience working at Carnegie was not positive. Speaking to your comment regarding keeping the acquisition"hush-hush", acquiring a business is a process that only involves those who are necessary. Carnegie and mStoner signed a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) even before due diligence began. The NDA protects both companies, vendors, customers, and employees from any risk. As Carnegie grows, and has acquired companies there are things that evolve, such as formalizing procedures, and transferring team members to other groups to utilize their talent. This takes time, and with all of Carnegie's growth this is an opportunity for our employees to define their future with us. Exit interviews are voluntary and confidential, and not once has Human Resources shared the information with anyone except the COO. What was mentioned in your exit interview was that if there was anything egregious, it would have to be shared, and in my 9 years at Carnegie there never has been. Data from these interviews has helped us add benefits, increase pay, and work towards making Carnegie a better place to work. Turnover at Carnegie is average, and many of our employees are leaving to work in different industries or for other opportunities. Nothing makes us happier than to be part of a prior employee's development and journey. Many of our former employees have been great ambassadors for Carnegie, and will always be part of the Carnegie family. Please feel free to contact me at hr@carnegiehighered.com if you have additional comments. Allison Letizi VP, Human Resources
Viewing 22 - 24 of 100 Reviews

Glassdoor has 103 Carnegie Dartlet reviews submitted anonymously by Carnegie Dartlet employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Carnegie Dartlet is right for you.