PMA Companies reviews

3.7

69% would recommend to a friend

(215 total reviews)
avatar

John Santulli

97% approve of CEO

70% positive business outlook

PMA Companies has an employee rating of 3.7 out of 5 stars, based on 215 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The PMA Companies employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

215 reviews
1.0
Mar 20, 2020
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great people - very friendly & welcoming Long tenured employees - some who’ve been with the company over 30+ years Great location - super convenient location and commute from my home Open door policy - senior leaders are open to walk-ins and impromptu meetings Good time off policy - 27 combined paid vacation, personal & sick days with the option to purchase 3 additional pto days

Cons

Stale insurance company set in its old school mentality Long tenured employees are great in many instances but the downside to having long tenured employees is their lack of understanding of how modern day operations work in corporate America. They only know and understand PMA’s structure. Terrible benefits - medical benefits are extremely expensive at $150 per paycheck. This is ridiculous especially for an insurance company. New managers who can come in & turn a department upside down, disrespecting employees, showing no regard for company policies & changing job descriptions without a care for their employees’ general interests. A new manager started at PMA and completely ruined a department by showing 0 respect for her team’s experience & not allowing herself to learn the company culture & structure. This leader is by far the worst micro manager I’ve ever experienced and here are the facts: She was hired to be 100% remote and when she met her team instantly decided that members on her team who were remote 1 day a week could no longer have that privilege (complete hypocrite, right?) Called employees on her team just to see what they’re doing and if they’re working Extremely disrespectful in many ways: 1. Answers personal calls during one on one meetings and has lengthy conversations, 2. Undoes and/or cancels any work her team members do and redoes it her way (shows no trust in her team’s ability to do their job), 3. Shows up very late to any or all meetings with no explanation (0 respect for people’s time- shows how she doesn’t value her team), 4. Talks bad about company employees including leadership and/or colleagues, company employee engagement activities and her feelings about the company by saying “I don’t know why I took this job” and “the company picnic is stupid”, 5. Completely cancels projects after approving them causing issues with both internal and external business partners (shows complete disrespect for the work that has been completed up to that point and how it impacts business partners & relationships) 6. Very rarely responded to e-mails and voicemails but everything she needed was “urgent”, 7. Treated employees like children and not exempt employees who know how to conduct themselves professionally (creating a calendar for time off approvals and requesting access to see everyone’s calendars, also asking to be copied on all e-mails and meetings) The worst part about all of this is the fact that her superiors failed to address these issues but instead swept them under the rug & ignored the issues completely. That taught me a lot about the company and its leadership. If things don’t change, this leader will run this department into a hole & drive her entire team away. This by far was the WORST micro management experience in my career and I’ve been working in corporate America for over 15 years for some very large, profitable corporations. HR doesn’t care about complaints either. You, the employee will look bad if you report an issue so don’t even bother! That’s a complete disgrace not to mention that HR consists of probably 10 people. If this terrible micro manager stays, the company will go downhill fast! I guarantee it.

3.0
Aug 9, 2018

"Company Men & Women"

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Stability, The company has been established for over 100 years. Most Employees there have worked there from anywhere to 25 - 45 years some straight out of high school. Very comfortable place to work.

Cons

Too Comfortable not challenging enough no room for Increase or growth of any kind. They give less than 2% yearly raises. Nice/Nasty employees who perfect phoniness. It's supposed to be a Businness environment but most persons are casual at best. Because of the stability of the job you can get comfortable being part of a culture of mediocrity. Employees get applauded for being in the same role for 40 years with no ambition for upward mobility. They're content with the 25 year relationship with coworkers and having a mundane career. Be careful not to get stuck here in the sunken place.

5.0
May 10, 2012
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I work for PMA Management Corp (on the tpa side). Both PMA Management Corp and PMA Insurance Group have strong dedicated leaders that care about customers/ insureds and also employees. Management is great at sharing knowledge and information. Employees want to see PMA succeed because we are treated fairly. Senior management gets involved with getting to know the customers and employees. PMA's leaders are quick to respond to business needs and changes. All of this makes PMA a profitable company. Employees work normal 40 work weeks. PMA focuses on what is important and in the best interest of customers/ insureds and employees and does not micromanage employees or create a lot of busy work like I have found to be the case at other carriers. I have an amazing team of people that I work with. Not only are the people I work with highly skilled and great adjusters but they're also just really nice genuine people. It feels so good to come into work everyday and really like the people you work with. Most of the senior managers have been at PMA for most or all of their career (with many over 20 years) so the company does a great job at promoting from within.

Cons

The annual salary increases and bonuses could be better but aren't awful. But I would take working at PMA for slightly less pay over a poor working environment that pays slightly more.

Viewing 7 - 9 of 215 Reviews

Glassdoor has 230 PMA Companies reviews submitted anonymously by PMA Companies employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if PMA Companies is right for you.